LAST CHANCE: Special 48 Hour Townhall Blowout Sale
Why Was a UN Worker Holding a Hostage in Gaza?
Does Nikki Haley Have a Vaccine Mandate Issue?
Kathy Hochul Is Getting Wrecked for Her George Santos Expulsion Tweet
We're Tired of Soft-Spine Conservatives
Federal Court: Trump NOT Immune From January 6 Lawsuits
Deadspin Is Being Mocked Relentlessly Over Shoddy Chiefs Fan Story
Showing How the Flood of ‘Trump Is a Nazi!’ Reports Have Nothing to...
Here We Go Again? Republican Senators Call for Travel Ban From China Over...
Uncle of Boys Held Hostage Says Hamas Branded the Children in Captivity
Texas AG Sues Pfizer, Alleging Company Misrepresented the Efficacy of the COVID-19 Vaccine
Brown University President Edits Remarks in Real Time When Confronted by Anti-Israel Heckl...
Yikes: Here's Who Put a Stop to the Newsom-DeSantis Debate
DeSantis and Newsom’s Fiery Exchange About Parental Rights
George Santos Expelled From the House


The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of

Heads of state -- presidents, prime ministers, dictators, whatever -- cannot possibly know everything that is going on in their country, much less in other countries. That's why, before a "summit" between heads of state, battalions of staffers go through every conceivable subject and produce forests of briefing papers to prepare the principal.


According to the late William Safire writing in the New York Times, the word "summit" to describe a meeting of heads of state was coined by (no surprise) Winston Churchill in 1950, when he called for a "parley on the summit" to chart the post-war world rather than, as Churchill put it, "hordes of experts and officials drawn up in a vast cumbrous array."

This is timely because in the past few weeks U.S. President Barack Obama had a summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping in California, followed by a G-8 summit in Northern Ireland.

At a meeting of multiple heads of state (or any other level-to-level officials), there are often side meetings between just two. These are called "bi-lateral" meetings or, in the manner of those involved, "a bi-lat."

Obama and Russian President Vladimir Putin engaged in a bi-lat that was largely focused on trying to find common ground on what to do about Syria -- ground that proved elusive.

George W. Bush's first European was with the very same President Putin -- Bush then proclaimed:

"I looked the man in the eye. I found him to be very straight forward and trustworthy and we had a very good dialogue. I was able to get a sense of his soul. He's a man deeply committed to his country and the best interests of his country and I appreciate very much the frank dialogue and that's the beginning of a very constructive relationship."

Notwithstanding the current status of Putin's soul, that is the very reason that heads-of-state like to meet one another in person, sometimes with only interpreters in the room.


Over a two week period Obama met with arguably his two most important competitors -- politically and economically -- in the world: Xi and Putin.

Although the White House declared that the men had wide-ranging discussions, we know that there were no broad agreements much less any breakthroughs in bi-lateral understanding.

One of the pre-summit issues that we expected Obama to raise with Xi was Chinese hacking of American computers. Unfortunately, the story broke at the same time as the National Security Administration's surveillance, so Obama was able to say, "If anyone is going to spy on Americans' cell phones and computer files, it will be the Americans."

Not exactly a firm footing for demanding better behavior by the Chinese.

With Putin's intractability - from the Obama point-of-view - over Syria and lack of enthusiasm for greater transparency in international financial transactions, not much came out of that bi-lat, either.

Now comes the odyssey of Edward Snowden -- leaker of the NSA information. Snowden had been an employee of government contractor Booz Allen Hamilton in Hawaii (following stints at the CIA and NSA), when he apparently stole and leaked the highly classified documents about the NSA's activities. He surfaced in Hong Kong, which until 1997 was a British Crown Colony and is now under the full control of the Chinese government.

Late last week, the U.S Government asked the Chinese to arrest Snowden and hold him for extradition. The Chinese government refused, saying that the U.S had not provided the full legal documentation necessary.


Over the weekend, it surfaced that Snowden was on the move to Moscow aboard an Aeroflot plane. He is expected to move from Russia to Cuba, then to Ecuador where he will request asylum.

Equador's embassy in London is where WikiLeaks head Julian Assange has been granted sanctuary, so Snowden's request may well be granted. It appears the State Department has finally gotten around to revoking Snowden's passport, so it will be interesting to see which country has issued Snowden the necessary documents to move through multiple immigration and customs lines.

All in all, the summits that President Obama attended with Xi and Putin do not appear to have had the hoped-for results: Better relations between the countries involved.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Videos