The Department of Education is often misleading, vague and ominous. An odd announcement from Secretary Arne Duncan states that his department’s Office of Civil Rights will “reinvigorate civil rights enforcement” in the nation’s schools in an effort “to make Dr. King’s dream of a colorblind society a reality.”
Most everyone agrees that ensuring civil rights in schools—that is, ensuring equitable opportunities for pupils of all backgrounds and ethnicities and educational abilities—is important and well worth the country’s aspiration. But Duncan and Assistant Secretary Russlynn Ali, who leads the Office of Civil Rights, have in mind a different definition of civil rights—one that seeks not equal opportunity but equal results. And in the course of their stated quest to ensure such an equality for certain groups of students (specifically, those who are black and Latino, poor, and learning disabled) Duncan and Ali will, unwittingly or otherwise, violate the rights of non-black-or-Latino, non-poor, and non-learning-disabled students.
Duncan, for instance, believes that the country must make certain “that low-income Latino and African American students” have the same access to the Advanced Placement (AP) program as other students. “White high school graduates are . . . more than twice as likely to have taken AP calculus classes as black or Latino high school graduates,” he said recently. To Duncan, what is troublingly unequal is troublingly unfair; he deduces that black and Latino students are mostly wrongly denied access to AP classes, on account of their ethnicities.
But this view denies reality. Black and Latino high-school students are simply less likely than their white and Asian counterparts to have attained the academic skills that AP requires. The solution is not to police the AP roll, ticking off its black, white, ecru, and persimmon pupils and insisting on some concocted golden ratio between them. The solution is to worry about the lousy elementary schools and middle schools where so many black and Latino kids are permitted to sit through years of classes while learning next to nothing. Fixing those schools would be a valuable civil-rights pursuit.
Contrast: David Cameron Suspends Vacation Over Foley Killing; Obama Heads Back To Vineyard | Christine Rousselle