New Video of Scottie Scheffler's Arrest Paints a Very Different Picture
Comedian Takes Aim at San Francisco's Anarchic Tendencies
You Have to Be an Exceptionally Bad President to Lose Silicon Valley
CBS News Polls the Uninformed, Biden Reads a Kenyan Script, and the Press...
The $400 Pineapple Is Now Sold Out in the US
The High Art of Virtue Signaling
Look What's Come Back to Haunt Hunter Biden at His Gun Trial
Opposition to U.S. Steel Deal is Misguided and Counterproductive
Red States Could End Up Paying for Blue States’ Climate Policies
As AZ Democrats Panic Over the ‘Secure the Border Act,’ Republicans Should Keep...
EVs Should Only Be for Consenting Adults
FIFA Is Latest Target of Palestinian Hijacking
Voters Reject Abortion Extremism from Barrow to Biden
This Mental Health Awareness Month, Let’s Focus on the Harm Social Media is...
Joe Biden's Latest 'Racist' Comment Is Low Even for Him

The (Liberal) Case Against Sotomayor?

Jeffrey Rosenberg is a legal writer who is definitely not part of the vast, right-wing conspiracy.  But even he, writing in The New Republic (a liberal-leaning magazine), makes a very effective case against Judge Sotomayor.  The pretty damning piece included the following evaluation by former law clerks (for other judges) and federal prosecutors:

Nearly all of them acknowledged that Sotomayor is a presumptive front-runner [for the Supreme Court seat], but nearly none of them raved about her. They expressed questions about her temperament, her judicial craftsmanship, and most of all, her ability to provide an intellectual counterweight to the conservative justices, as well as a clear liberal alternative.

Rosen notes that the clerks, in particular, had no axe to grind with Sotomayor.  If what they said is true (and no doubt we'll learn lots from the hearings), Barack Obama decided it was more important to hew strictly to political considerations -- trying to lock in the Latino vote, keeping the far left happy -- than to appoint a judicial mind of the first caliber.

Telling, isn't it, if ethnicity, gender and politics trumped every other consideration for the President? 

If some of the piece's details about Sotomayor's behavior on the bench are true, it will be interesting -- if she is confirmed -- to watch her go head-to-head with Justice Scalia.


Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Videos