Tim Alberta Just Said Something That Should Send Dems Into Total Panic
A Major Lie From the Secret Service About the Trump Assassination Attempt Just...
And We Have Another Brutal Development on the Trump Assassination Attempt
The Idea of Changing Your Mind Confuses Democrats
Republicans Roar Out of Milwaukee Confident of November Victory
A Quick Bible Study Vol. 226: Psalm Summer - Part 3
Grover Cleveland, Long Before Donald Trump
Iran Threat on the Global Stage: Resistance, Elections, and the Western Dilemma
Big Labor Comes for the House
Donald Trump’s Shooter — A Product of Government Schools’ Indoctrination?
JD Vance Will Protect American Workers
Exposing the Lies of Socialism
Vance Should Not Cower From Abortion Controversy
Does Gretchen Whitmer Have What It Takes to be President?
One Week After Trump Was Nearly Assassinated, He Takes the Stage Again

Refugees and, Maybe, What to Do About Them

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
AP Photo/Marco Ugarte

We just can't kick the habit. Or the media can't, which comes to the same thing, given the media's habitual deference to its customers -- you and me and Neighbor Jones.


We'd rather hear about Donald Trump than about the specific problem he believes himself, on particular occasions, to be addressing. And so today's big story on the Mexican border mess is all about DJT's "purge of the nation's immigration and security leadership," to quote The New York Times.

The story is a story. But it is not THE story: the story, that is, of a mass migration that existing governmental procedures are too weak to inhibit. Thus, what do we do? How do we preserve America's reputation as a simultaneously welcoming and politically stable country? Is Trump advancing the cause or not when he shows Kirstjen Nielsen the door -- none too genteelly, we may assume -- as secretary of Homeland Security and proceeds from there to overhaul the top ranks of the department?

The answer likely depends on your opinion of Trump -- as do all judgments to which we are dolefully invited these days.

Either the chief magistrate is a low-rent swine, or he's a faithful laborer against the "deep state." Such are the choices with which political discourse, online or at the microphone, usually leaves us. Left undusted-off are the underlying questions: What's the problem? What needs doing about it?

You don't get by for long without posing, and attempting to answer, those questions. I suspect most of us would not recognize Ms. Nielsen if she were ahead of us in the Kroger checkout line. I suspect most of us, without much labor, could imagine the implications of turning the Southwestern United States into a destination for every Honduran, Guatemalan or Salvadoran with a painful story to tell about life back home.


This matter is a hard one -- painfully hard. The United States, place the president's assertions and the absurdity of his threats to "close" the U.S.-Mexico border (talk about unbelievable promises and undoable tasks!) has ever welcomed refugees and always will -- however, on its own terms, not the terms of those who've decided to live in the American house, never mind what the landlord says.

Here we come to the nub of the matter. You can't just say, "Come one, come all." Is that the progressive position? One can't tell inasmuch as progressives and their news media cheering section prefer railing at the inhumane Trump to putting forth ideas that address the perils of "Come one, come all."

I have been on church mission trips to Honduras. The Hondurans are, as Texans say, good folks. But is opening wide the gates to them, and to others from the region, the answer to their hardships? This does not compute.

Corrupt government and the disappearance of social morale -- leading to poverty, economic sloth and gang-led crime -- have pointed many to the conclusion that flight is the only answer. The United States should act all the more sympathetically here for having failed, first, to recognize an obvious interest in the welfare of neighboring nations and, second, to create aid programs that enhance democratic capitalism and personal safety. However, from America's blindness to patent needs you can't jump to some fanciful American duty to make up for it all through general overhaul of its laws and policies governing refugees. The political instinct so to do is the same that stokes ever-sillier, ever-more-fervent talk of financial "reparations" to the descendants of African slaves.


No nation does everything right. No nation can, given the ongoing defects of human nature. Anyway, it's too late for replanting the Garden of Eden.

The best America can do about the refugee tide to the south is to:

1. Establish firm control of the situation.

2. Enlist conservatives and liberals alike, as many as can be induced into such an unsavory alliance, to fashion for Central America an aid program that actually aids in addressing the afflictions of crime, subpar economic development and venal government.

Well, it beats chewing the rug over Trump any old day of the week, doesn't it?

William Murchison is writing a book on American moral restoration in the 21st century. His latest book is "The Cost of Liberty: The Life of John Dickinson." 


Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Videos