Garrett Murch

Throughout the Bush Administration years, Maine's Republican senators, Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins, successfully honed their hard-earned reputations as 'moderates'. Whether opposing tax cuts, supporting caps on Carbon Dioxide emissions, blocking passage of free trade agreements and drilling in the Arctic, or breaking with their party on numerous other occasions, one or the other (and often both) frequently and effectively checked the power of Republican rule – much to the chagrin of their GOP colleagues.

As a result, the people of Maine, rightfully suspicious of unchecked power, have rewarded their independent senators by repeatedly returning them to office. As of January 20, 2009, however, there has been no Republican rule to balance. Barack Obama is President and has healthy Democratic majorities in both the House and Senate. The only remaining Republican power rests in its potential to filibuster – and thus block – legislation supported by the Democratic House, Senate Democrats and the Obama Administration.

With this new power paradigm, the role of a 'moderate' Republican in the U.S. Senate has turned on its head. Rather than curbing the perceived excesses of their own party, a 'moderate' Republican senator – to deserve the label – must stick with her party in preventing passage of extreme liberal legislation. Breaks with Republicans on critical votes will denote a liberal, not moderate, Republican, as the once-pipe dreams of Speaker Nancy Pelosi and the liberal Democratic base are now just a vote or two away from becoming a reality.

Take a few examples. The Senate will soon take up the massive spending bill – misleadingly labeled a ‘stimulus’ package – that reads like a liberal wish list. The spending bill was opposed by all House Republicans as well as a number of Democrats, yet was rammed through the House by Speaker Pelosi. Could this legislation rightly be called moderate?

There will likely be a vote this year on labor unions' push to eliminate the secret ballot vote that even liberal former presidential candidate George McGovern has outspokenly opposed. Would a moderate support eliminating the sacred right to vote in privacy, simply to curry favor with big labor bosses struggling to retain union membership?


Garrett Murch

Garrett Murch is a writer and a former aide to Sen. Olympia Snowe.