Tipsheet

Media Demonstrates Double Standard on Gov. Kemp's and Gov. Polis's Similar Reopening Plans

Reagan McCarthy
Reagan McCarthy  |  April 24, 2020 11:20 AM

Democrats and members of the mainstream media spent much of the week unloading on Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp (R-GA) after he announced that certain businesses in Georgia would be allowed to resume operations starting on Friday. 

Gov. Kemp’s decision triggered a wave of backlash as many claimed that his decision was irresponsible. Media outlets also took advantage of President Trump’s amicable disagreement with Gov. Kemp’s move, in an attempt to undermine Kemp’s jurisdiction to reopen his state under the 10th amendment. Though the president publicly expressed his disagreement with Gov. Kemp’s decision to reopen parts of his state, the president has remained nuanced and respectful of governors doing the jobs to which they were elected throughout this crisis. President Trump and Gov. Kemp made it clear that they talked at length about Kemp's decision, and the president repeatedly said that he respected Kemp's choice despite disagreement.

The president reaffirmed this morning that he did not endorse Gov. Kemp's eventual decision, but that it is the Georgia Republican's job to govern as he sees fit:

Gov. Kemp vehemently defended his decision, but was spared no criticism from mainstream media outlets:

“Public health experts have expressed concern with Kemp’s plan and warned that moving too quickly could fuel a resurgence in infections. The conflicting messages from state and federal officials have left many business owners in Georgia confused. Some are embracing the governors’ order and making plans to reopen, while others say it’s not worth the potential risk to employees and customers,” the Associated Press wrote of Gov. Kemp’s decision.

While Kemp bore the brunt of the media’s backlash, his Democratic colleague, Colorado Gov. Jared Polis (D), received no criticism on a mirror-image decision to reopen parts of Colorado’s economy. 

Recommended

Is This Why Gaetz Withdrew His Name From Consideration for Attorney General? Matt Vespa
FEMA Director Denies, Denies, Denies Mia Cathell

Gov. Polis announced reopening plans with a similar timeline to that of Gov. Kemp’s plan, but was not vilified by the media, presumably due to his party identification:

“Gov. Jared Polis outlined a plan to ease statewide stay-at-home and nonessential business closures Monday. All nonessential retailers may soon offer curbside delivery and can fully reopen, at half-staff capacity and with protective measures. Offices and personal services can do the same in May. Schools, universities, gyms remain closed, along with indoor restaurant and bar service,” the AP wrote of Gov. Polis’s similar decision.

While the media crucified Gov. Kemp’s governance, his state’s statistics surrounding COVID-19 are much more favorable than that of Colorado. Per RealClearPolitics, Georgia’s death-per-million rate is 83, while Colorado’s is 95; Georgia has given 101,062 COVID-19 tests, while Colorado has given 52,324. 

As President Trump makes clear, there is plenty of room for disagreement with the decisions of individual governors, whether Republican or Democrat. Ideology should not be the litmus test for the media to fairly represent the decisions of governors, and the double standard here is alarming; while headlines call Gov. Kemp “irresponsible,” and gives the majority of attention to Democrats’ criticism of his decision, a Democratic governor who issued a similar decision is exempt from disapproval. 

Editor's Note: Want to support Townhall so we can keep telling the truth about China and the virus they unleashed on the world? Join Townhall VIP and use the promo code WUHAN to get 25% off VIP membership!