Analysis: What's behind release of 2 Americans

AP News
Posted: Nov 09, 2014 4:18 AM
Analysis: What's behind release of 2 Americans

TOKYO (AP) — While the details behind the release of the final two Americans held in North Korea — Matthew Miller of Bakersfield, California, and Kenneth Bae of Lynnwood, Washington — are still unclear, here are questions and some answers as to what might have motivated the North to let the two men out.



A: Pyongyang apparently got at least one thing it wanted: A senior U.S. official had to come personally to retrieve the two Americans. James Clapper, the director of national intelligence, was the highest-ranking American to visit Pyongyang in more than a decade.

A senior Obama administration official said Clapper spent roughly a day on the ground and met with North Korean security officials — but not with leader Kim Jong Un.

Clapper went with the sole purpose of bringing home the two detainees, although the U.S. anticipated that other issues of concern to the North would come up during his discussions, according to the official traveling with Obama to Beijing. The official said that North Koreans indicated in recent weeks that they would release the detainees if the U.S. sent a high-level official from Obama's administration.

Clapper's visit in itself is something of a coup for Pyongyang, which has for months been pursuing a high-profile campaign to keep the detainees' situation on Washington's radar.

As part of that effort, the North had allowed the men, along with a third detainee, Jeffrey Fowle, who was released last month, to meet with The Associated Press and other media. The AP met with Fowle and Miller three times. Each time, they pleaded for a senior U.S. statesman to come and bail them out.

That has been the pattern in past releases. Previously, trips have been made by former Presidents Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton.

Pyongyang tends to view such visits as stature-boosting evidence that is tantamount to an official apology — though U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said recently that Washington had no intention of offering any official apology to Pyongyang as a quid pro quo.



A: There is growing concern in North Korea over international pressure in connection with its human rights record. A recent U.N. report documented rape, torture, executions and forced labor in the North's network of prison camps, accusing the government of "widespread, systematic and gross" human rights violations.

North Korea strongly denies those allegations, which it claims are based mainly on politically motivated statements from defectors. It released a counter document of its own in September, but is worried about efforts to bring the issue before the International Criminal Court.

Its state media recently have been filled with angry accusations that the United States, South Korea and their allies are trying to use the human rights issue as a weapon to bring down the North Korean government, calling it a "racket" and pointing out problems with the United States' own rights record.

Pyongyang has portrayed similar releases of American detainees in the past as humanitarian decisions, and a likely similar portrayal of the latest releases could point to an important motive behind the decision.



A: Bae had been held since November 2012, when he was detained while leading a tour group in a special North Korean economic zone. He was convicted of conducting "hostile acts" after being accused of smuggling in inflammatory literature and trying to establish a base for anti-government activities at a border city hotel.

Bae, 46, is a Korean-American missionary, and his family believes he was detained because of his Christian faith.

Miller's case remains mysterious.

He entered the country on April 10 on a tourist visa, allegedly ripped up the document at Pyongyang's airport and demanded asylum. North Korean authorities say he intended to conduct espionage while in the country. During his brief trial, prosecutors said he admitted having the "wild ambition" of experiencing prison life so that he could secretly investigate North Korea's human rights situation.


Eric Talmadge is the AP's Pyongyang bureau chief.

Follow him on Twitter at