EU treads carefully on Libya no-fly zone

AP News
Posted: Mar 09, 2011 5:53 PM
EU treads carefully on Libya no-fly zone

European governments are expected to adopt more sanctions against Libyan strongman Moammar Gadhafi in coming days but shy away from military measures like a no-fly zone without U.N. backing _ as ongoing fighting, Arab public opinion, and a checkered history of intervention give them reason for caution.

European Union foreign ministers Thursday pave the way for a summit of government leaders a day later that will toughen earlier measures against Gadhafi and his closest associates with fresh financial sanctions, and arrange more humanitarian aid to help the evacuation of people fleeing the fighting.

Robust action like imposing a no-fly zone over the country to keep Gadhafi's warplanes from attacking rebels is unlikely.

"Everything that goes beyond targeted sanctions must be mandated by the United Nations and must, above all, have the backing of the Arab League," German Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle said Wednesday.

He and others in the EU stressed it is important to avoid providing fuel to Gadhafi's propaganda claims that the rebellion isn't a popular movement and is Western-inspired instead.

Before adopting any bolder steps, the Europeans were also looking to a meeting of the Arab League on Saturday to gauge the strength of regional support for a no-fly zone to contain the fighting in Libya, said a senior EU official who spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the situation. The African Union's Peace and Security Council is also expected to meet in the coming days.

Britain and France have drafted a U.N. resolution that would impose a no-fly zone over Libya, but Western diplomats _ speaking on condition of anonymity because discussions on a no-fly zone have taken place in private _ have said it will not be introduced at the Security Council unless several "triggers" are met, first and foremost support from the major regional players, the Arab League and the African Union.

"You are talking about military intervention to get rid of one government and putting another one in place," said the senior EU official. "You have to think twice before doing anything of that sort. This would put us in a very delicate situation with many Arab populations. This is what it is all about."

Most of the other 25 EU nations have taken a cautious approach to the no-fly zone which will limit room for maneuver at Friday's summit

The other key trigger that Western countries will be looking for is the killing of civilians by Libyan warplanes on a large-scale that presumably could be curbed by imposing a no-fly zone, the diplomats said.

If the Arab League and African Union support a no-fly zone, the diplomats said they believe China won't block a resolution and Russia might be swayed. The diplomats don't believe either Moscow or Beijing have ruled out a U.N. resolution, though both are skeptical.

Many EU nations will also take part in Thursday's meeting of NATO defense ministers across town in Brussels, where the no-fly zone will also be discussed.

There, too, allied nations were agreed that for NATO to act there would have to be a demonstrable need for such a mission, regional support in the Arab world and Africa, and a clear legal basis for it, said a senior U.S. official, who spoke on condition of anonymity due to standing rules.

"We would welcome a U.N. Security Council resolution, we would want one," he said. At the moment, veto-holding Security Council members China and Russia oppose such a move.

With Iraq and Afghanistan in mind, many are fearful any military action could spell the beginning of a long engagement.

"We must also take care that we do not slide onto a slope at the end of which we could find ourselves in a lasting military conflict, at the end of which we could effectively be a party in a civil war," Westerwelle said.

Italy insists a strong international mandate will be necessary for a no-fly zone, or any military operation in Libya. Rome has offered its bases to be used for any enforcement of a possible no-fly zone, but Foreign Minister Franco Frattini has ruled out any Italian military intervention in the country because of Italy's past as Libya's colonial ruler.

Frattini insisted that imposing a no-fly zone would require broad international consensus and could not be left to a "coalition of the willing." He said a no-fly zone is "not a videogame."

The U.S. official noted, though, that there had been a noticeable decline in Libyan air attacks on insurgents in recent days. And he said there had been no evidence of any large-scale and indiscriminate bombardment of civilian populations.

Over the past days, EU member states have been preparing measures to turn the financial screw on Gadhafi and a full deal to target more international assets and companies linked to the regime could be completed on Friday. After a tentative agreement in Brussels the proposals are currently in the national capitals awaiting further approval.

"We have to prevent the ruling family in Libya being able to get fresh money ... so that the dictator cannot recruit any new mercenaries," Westerwelle said.

Two high-level officials from an opposition group fighting Gadhafi are expected to have diplomatic meetings in Brussels as the ministers and leaders are gathering.

The European Parliament's major political groups want the EU nations to recognize the umbrella group for eastern rebels, the newly created Interim Governing Council in Benghazi. EU officials said, however, that was unlikely to happen at this early stage.


AP writers Slobodan Lekic from Brussels, Geir Moulson from Berlin and Edith Lederer at the United Nations contributed to this report.