McCain vows to reinstate U.S. curb on Russian rocket engines

Reuters News
Posted: Jan 27, 2016 10:49 AM

By Andrea Shalal

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman John McCain on Wednesday said he planned to introduce legislation that would strike language included in a massive 2016 spending bill that eased a congressional ban on the use of Russian rocket engines.

McCain said he would introduce the legislation on Thursday, the first of many actions he planned "to ensure we end our dependence on Russian rocket engines and stop subsidizing Vladimir Putin and his gang of corrupt cronies."

Congress banned use of the Russian RD-180 rocket engines for military use after Russia annexed Ukraine's Crimea region in 2014. But U.S. lawmakers weakened the ban late last year, worried that it could drive United Launch Alliance, a joint venture of Lockheed Martin Corp and Boeing Co, out of business and leave just one other U.S. provider, privately-held SpaceX, to lift satellites into space.

Top Pentagon and Air Force officials on Wednesday urged the committee to allow use of the Russian engines until alternatives were available, and said they were moving ahead with plans to fund new public-private launch services in fiscal year 2017.

Defense Undersecretary Frank Kendall, the Pentagon's chief arms buyer, told the committee it was questionable whether ULA could survive if the U.S. military immediately stopped using the Russian RD-180 engine that powers ULA's Atlas 5 rocket.

He said ULA had a second rocket, the Delta 4, that did not use the RD-180 engines, but that vehicle cost "millions of dollars more" than the Atlas 5 rocket and could not compete with cheaper launches provided by privately-held SpaceX.

The Air Force last year certified technology entrepreneur Elon Musk's SpaceX to execute military launches, but has not yet awarded a contract to the company.

Kendall said losing ULA would leave the military relying only on SpaceX for launches, despite a policy that requires two ways to launch satellites into space.

McCain and other senators urged the department to provide data on the exact cost of switching to the Delta 4 rocket until other options were available. They said they backed spending more money on that rocket, rather than buying Russian engines.

ULA's recent order of 20 more Russian engines amounted to a "a nearly half-billion-dollar windfall" for Russia, McCain said.

McCain also questioned why the Defense Department was still doing business with NPO Energomash, the Russian company that builds the RD-180 engines, given sanctions in place against Russian individuals, including Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin and others, who now have control over the company.

Air Force Secretary Deborah James told McCain that given recent changes in management of the Russian space sector, she had asked Pentagon legal and policy officials to work with the State, Commerce and Treasury departments to reassess a previous ruling that had allowed continued dealings with Energomash.

McCain also blasted ULA for refusing to bid in an Air Force launch competition last year, despite receiving billions of dollars in government funding to maintain its launch capability.

At the time, ULA, the monopoly provider of such launches since its creation in 2006, said it was unable to submit a compliant bid because it lacked enough RD-180 engines and did not have the accounting systems to comply with government rules.

Deputy Secretary Robert Work told McCain in a letter dated Jan. 26 that he disagreed with ULA over the accounting systems, and believed ULA would now be willing to compete.

James told the committee the Air Force was looking at possible ways to sanction ULA for refusing to bid in the competition, including early termination of a contract that provides the firm about $800 million a year in support funding.

ULA spokeswoman Jessica Rye declined to comment on possible penalties. She said ULA remained focused on providing "rock-solid reliable launch services for the nation's most critical satellites."

(Editing by Jeffrey Benkoe and Tom Brown)