Indian government clashes with southern state over Gandhi killers

Reuters News
Posted: Feb 20, 2014 7:44 AM

By Shyamantha Asokan

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - India's government was embroiled in a dispute on Thursday with a powerful state that plans to free seven people convicted for the 1991 killing of former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi, in political jostling ahead of a general election.

The assassination by a suicide bomber is an emotional issue for India's ruling Congress party, led by the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty, which is gearing up for an election expected to start in April. Gandhi's widow, Sonia, is Congress' president and their son, Rahul, is leading the party's election campaign.

The state of Tamil Nadu plans to release the convicts in what is seen as a pitch for votes by Jayaram Jayalalithaa, chief minister of the southern state where there is some sympathy for the killers' political motives.

Jayalalithaa, who announced the plan on Wednesday, is thought to have national ambitions.

"The assassination of Shri Rajiv Gandhi was an attack on the soul of India," Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said in a statement on Thursday.

"The release of the killers of a former prime minister of India and our great leader, as well as several other innocent Indians, would be contrary to all principles of justice."

Gandhi was killed while campaigning in the state by an ethnic Tamil suicide bomber from the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), a separatist rebel group from neighboring Sri Lanka. Twenty-six people were convicted in 1998 for their roles in planning and carrying out the murder.

Ethnic Tamils are the majority community in Tamil Nadu and a minority in Sri Lanka where the government finally crushed the LTTE rebels in 2009, after a 26-year war.

India's government also filed a petition at the Supreme Court arguing that Jayalalithaa's state government did not have the power to free the ethnic Tamil convicts. The court blocked the chief minister from releasing three of them until the case was resolved and scheduled a hearing for March 6.

"Our stand is that the state of Tamil Nadu is fully empowered to consider the release of these persons," Rakesh Trivedi, a lawyer representing the state, told reporters outside the Supreme Court.

Whether Tamil Nadu would free the other four convicts before the case concluded was not yet clear, Trivedi said.


A 26-year war between Sri Lanka's government and the LTTE ended in 2009 when the separatists were finally crushed.

Jayalalithaa's move this week was a bid to woo voters in her state ahead of the parliamentary elections, by showing that she can outdo her rivals when it comes to supporting Tamils and standing up to New Delhi, analysts said.

"In Tamil Nadu, it's a battle of one-upmanship between the parties - they take positions which show that they are champions of the Tamil cause," said R Rangarajan, the editor of two news websites in the state capital Chennai.

"But the average person is not so much worried about this issue (of the convicts). There is a broad feeling of support for the Sri Lankan Tamils, but not for the militancy."

Congress' national rival, the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is forecast to emerge as the biggest party in the election, but to fall short of the 272 seats needed for a majority. Whoever forms India's next government will likely have to win over some regional parties and form a coalition.

Jayalalithaa is a key player, with her party forecast to pick up as many as 23 seats, according to an opinion poll last month by pollsters CSDS for the CNN-IBN news channel. Her party said last year it wanted her to become prime minister.

India's Supreme Court this week commuted death sentences for three of the convicts in the Gandhi case to life sentences, paving the way for their release given that they have spent more than 20 years in jail. The other four convicts were already serving life sentences.

(Additional reporting by Suchitra Mohanty in NEW DELHI; Editing by Frank Jack Daniel and Robert Birsel)