Moscow court confirms election defeat for Navalny

AP News
Posted: Sep 20, 2013 10:21 AM
Moscow court confirms election defeat for Navalny

MOSCOW (AP) — A Moscow courthouse on Friday upheld the results of mayoral elections in which the Kremlin-backed incumbent narrowly avoided a run-off with opposition leader Alexei Navalny, Russian news outlets reported.

The judge rejected Navalny's claims that the campaign was marked by abuse of government finances and selected voter fraud, ruling that there were no grounds for a recount.

Navalny's success in the elections proved an embarrassment to his Kremlin-backed opponent, incumbent Sergei Sobyanin. Sobyanin got 51 percent of the vote, just avoiding the 50 percent cut-off that would have forced him into a second round against Navalny.

Independent election monitor Golos also criticized the election result, saying that there had been no evidence of widespread vote-rigging but that isolated violations could have tipped the close election.

Also Friday, another court that Navalny's appeals trial will begin on Oct. 9. Navalny was sentenced in July to five years in prison for embezzlement in a case that he and his supporters describe as legally dubious and a punishment for his exposure of high-level corruption.

He left the courtroom in handcuffs, but a day later in a surprise turnaround, prosecutors requested he be set free until the sentence was approved on appeal.

Most have speculated that it was Sobyanin who had Navalny set free, in order to ensure that the elections would look fair and competitive, giving legitimacy to the Kremlin candidate. But instead, Navalny rattled nerves in the elite with an unexpectedly good result, snagging 27 percent of the vote.

What Does Female Empowerment Mean?
Dennis Prager

The opposition activist's strong showing at the polls could be reflected in the appeal case, as his growing publicity and proven popularity could make it riskier than before to put him behind bars. When Navalny was first convicted, several thousand people filled the streets of Moscow to protest the court's decision.

Navalny will contest both the verdict and the sentencing of the trial. But even if the sentence is reduced or if he receives a suspended sentence, anything but an innocent verdict — rare in Russia's judicial system — would disqualify him from running for political office according to Russian law.