Addressing a meeting of Planned Parenthood last Friday, President Obama
accused pro-lifers of wanting to "turn back the clock to policies more
suited to the 1950s than the 21st century."
Like any decade, the '50s had its problems -- racism, discrimination,
sexism -- but I'll defend the '50s on other grounds, if the president will
defend the decade that followed. In the '50s, for much of mainstream America
drugs were something you bought at a pharmacy with a prescription; living
together meant getting married first, then having babies; abortion was not
legal; our culture wasn't the enemy; metal detectors were instruments one
took to the beach to find loose change and schools and the streets were
It's "Ozzie and Harriet" vs. Woodstock.
Dr. Kermit Gosnell is on trial now in a Philadelphia courtroom indicted on
charges that he performed late-term abortions and killed babies born alive
during the procedures. Is this the 21 century the president prefers? It is
actions like this -- not the policies of the '50s -- that have weakened
America and harmed the women the president claims to be defending.
How many women has the president talked to who lament their abortions and
say they would have made another choice, if they had been shown
alternatives? Does the president champion the rights of these women?
According to FactCheck.org, as an Illinois state senator, Obama twice voted
against the so-called "born-alive" bills that would have "defined any
aborted fetus that showed signs of life as a 'born alive infant' entitled to
legal protection." He opposed the bills, he said, "as backdoor attacks on a
woman's legal right to abortion." He chose politics, not lives.
In his speech to Planned Parenthood, the president never mentioned the word
"abortion," preferring to talk instead about "women's health." Could it be
because 40 years after the historic Roe v. Wade decision, public opinion on
abortion has changed very little? For the most part, those who favor it,
favor it; those who do not, do not.
The president and Planned Parenthood's other defenders claim that if the
organization were to be denied tax dollars, there would be fewer mammograms,
cancer screenings and other services available, especially to poor women. Is
this anything more than a distraction from Planned Parenthood's real
purpose -- providing abortions?
According to analysis from the Chiaroscuro Foundation, a not-for-profit
organization seeking to reduce the number of abortions in New York, Planned
Parenthood "provides more abortions than any other organization in the
United States, about one of every four U.S. abortions."
"Planned Parenthood's bottom line is numbers," according to a 2011 op-ed for
The Hill newspaper written by former clinic director Abby Johnson, "And,
with abortion as its primary money-maker, that means implementing a quota.
... I was directed to double the numbers of abortions our clinic performed
in order to drive up revenue."
Planned Parenthood spends a lot on electing liberal Democrats to office. It
can afford to. According to its 2011-2012 annual report, the organization
reported more than $1.2 billion in net assets and received a record $542
million in taxpayer funding. The pro-life Susan B. Anthony List has compiled
the "Top 12 Reasons to Defund Planned Parenthood Now"
Planned Parenthood and the left are inextricably linked. The organization
works to elect Democratic candidates who will defend their mission and those
candidates, once elected, fuel Planned Parenthood's agenda by funneling tax
dollars their way and trumpeting their "good works" in the name of women's
health. And millions of American children are aborted. This is what the 21st
century has to offer us? This is what we should prefer over the '50s?
A 1962 hit song looked back on the stability of the '50s and the values that
shaped the decade. It was called "That's Old Fashioned." The Everly Brothers
sang it. One of the verses goes:
"It's a modern changing world
Everything is moving fast
But when it comes to love I like
What they did in the past."
That beats some of the lyrics from the psychedelic '60s. By comparison,
the'50s look pretty good to me.