this is from:
http://townhall.com/columnists/PaulGreenberg/2007/02/27/on_fighting_the_problem?page=full&comments=truewhere I replied to Loribme's similar assertions earlier this year.
Loribme writes: Tuesday, February, 27, 2007 11:20 PM
“Everyonesfacts You keep bringing up the Declaration of Independence
but you neglect a vital part of that document: the men who wrote and
signed it EARNED their right to be called American because they
sacrificed EVERYTHING to escape tyranny and oppression to form a new
nation.”
And I would argue that many immigrants sacrifice everything to escape
tyranny and oppression and to pursue a better life as immigrants to America always have.
Loribme writes:
“They also wrote it (and the Constitution) for AMERICANS, not the rest of the world!”
The Constitution is written as the governing document of the USA.
The Declaration of Independence is written for at least three audiences
1. Colonists/Americans, 2. King George III / British, 3. “a candid WORLD”
And furthermore to quote from the document
“we believe that ALL MEN”
That’s pretty much everyone, I would humbly include women too
Loribme writes:
“Oh, and another thing: ALL of the signers of both those documents were
1) white men, 2) British citizens, 3) on British soil, 4) native to well established British colonies. THOSE were the original Americans!“
Yes, we are agreed except for “Those were the original Americans.”
Just to put a finer point on it. Africans, especially free blacks, were also
"original Americans." As were Indians, especially the “praying Indians,”
in the colonies. So yes those were original Americans but not "the"
original Americans.