If you look at all the studies you will notice that thinking with the head has better outcomes for everybody. In contrast, to excuse political rhetoric, false narratives and muddled thinking as coming from sincere hearts, is just gullibility. It is hard enough to think clearly and harder still to gather enough information and theory to think productively. Thinking with the heart assumes that one can think clearly in the absence of observation, historical records and theory. Of course even more important is to recognize the limits of our knowledge, so that common sense is always a good place to begin.