peaceman, if the Soul is making a choice, how would you know this? You are equivocating on the meaning of choice. What you are saying is, even if I don't know it, my Soul is making a choice.
Obviously, that is a conclusion which you think is a rational inference that you have drawn by stepping back from all experience. I disagree, because as I stated earlier, your point of view implies that an individual life is not worth as much as I believe it to be worth. I know when my Soul makes a choice, when I know that I make a choice. My soul is me, not some foreign thing that operates without my knowledge.
If you are right, human choices are irrelevant. My experience leads me to the opposite conclusion: EVERY choice is relevant.