Wasn't the whole point of the term "natural born" specifically for eligibility for the office of the Presidency? I mean didn't the founding fathers want people who's allegiance was to America and not the country their parents came from? Meaning the parents should also be citizens so the allegiance wouldn't be questioned.
So basically what York is saying is that the pregnant illegal Mexican running over the border to give birth to her child in the parking lot of the closest Piggly Wiggly, that child is eligible to be President of the United States? The obvious allegiance of this child is to Mexico where that child's parents are from, not the United States.