Over at HughHewitt.com I have ventured the opinion that perhaps --just perhaps-- originalists will eventually recognize Chief Justice Robert's decision and opinion yesterday as a bit of judicial genius that will be his Marbury v. Madison --the case that at first glance seemed a win for an executive whom the then Chief Justice opposed but which was in reality a huge win for the Court and the original design of the Constitution.
We won't have even a preliminary assessment for at least four months, and even if Mitt Romney wins the presidency, the success of this...
Join the Debate!
All comments and users are subject to Townhall's new comments policy.
Login in to Post Your Comments
John1921 Wrote: Jun 30, 2012 2:06 PM
Let's start with one of Life's Truths -- the right thing to do is simple, and hard; the wrong thing is complex, nuanced, out-of-the-box; and easy. O'bwanaCare is un-Constitutional. The 'mandate' is un-Constitutional as a direct tax, an excise, an income tax, or as a penalty (because the central govt has no authority to regulate the practice of medicine, except in DC). Roberts came to his moment of truth, wet his pants, and ran like a rabbit. Snivelling cowardice is never pleasant to watch, but Roberts chickened out on center stage. Why anyone would aspire to follow the path of John Marshall, a political hack and liar, I haven't figured. The Constitution specifically incorporated the Common Law of England as the foundation of the US legal sy
Login to Reply
Flag as Offensive
Post Comment
John1921 Wrote: Jun 30, 2012 2:23 PM
stem. Under that system, no English court had the power to void an act of Parliament as un-Constitutional, although acts could be void for vagueness. To boot, any decision/ruling of any English court could be reversed by vote of the House of Lords. Obviously, there was no provision for judicial review/supremacy in the Constitution, as ratified. We might also note that the "power to tax = power to destroy" consideration was exactly the reason the Federalists (think, Leftists) highjacked the Articles of Condederation in the first place -- under the Articles, the central govt had no taxing power.
Login to Reply
Flag as Offensive
Post Comment
There are More Comments on this Thread. Click Here To See them All
John1921 Wrote: Jun 30, 2012 2:34 PM
Recall that these same leftists/Federalists were treasonously aiding the Brit enemy during the War of 1812. Heck, the same white-hating Radical Republicans were the carpetbaggers and scalawags enforcing our first Affirmative Action program against whites during Reconstruction. Anybody who thinks it's too early to judge the French Revo is an idiot or a bloodthirsty Leftist deviant. Chou was both, in spades (sorry, Eric H). Edmonf Burke figured it all out before the Reign of Terror. But for every single Leftist who ever lived, the RoT was the justification for the Revo, not an aberration. Learn it; live it.
Login to Reply
Flag as Offensive
Post Comment
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Parker: How Abortion Has Changed America
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Kieffer: BENGHAZIGATE: Obama’s Secret Gun-Running Program
- Barone: Benghazi Report Revives Troubling Questions
- Schlichter: Can Marco Rubio Save Marco Rubio From Himself?
- Ransom: The Dishonorable Liberal Order of Regulatory Scientists
- Cannon: Obama’s Damaging Admission
- Mitchell: To Punch a Liberal
- Calculations: The Myth of Michelle Obama's "Food Desert"
- Mitchell: Canada Wants to Join the Government Stupidity Contest
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Ransom: Liberals Suck at Math and Eyeballs
- Parker: How Abortion Has Changed America
- Hunter: Creating Monsters: Terrorism, Welfare and “Celebrating Diversity”
- Kieffer: BENGHAZIGATE: Obama’s Secret Gun-Running Program
- Giles: Jihad On Our Tax Dollars? Screw That.
- Barone: Benghazi Report Revives Troubling Questions
- Schlichter: Can Marco Rubio Save Marco Rubio From Himself?
- Ransom: The Dishonorable Liberal Order of Regulatory Scientists
- Cannon: Obama’s Damaging Admission
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Ransom: Liberals Suck at Math and Eyeballs
- Parker: How Abortion Has Changed America
- Glick: Time to Confront Obama
- Hunter: Creating Monsters: Terrorism, Welfare and “Celebrating Diversity”
- O'Reilly: Droning On
- Hawkins: 7 Things Every Moderate Muslim Should Believe
- Kieffer: BENGHAZIGATE: Obama’s Secret Gun-Running Program
- Giles: Jihad On Our Tax Dollars? Screw That.
- Barone: Benghazi Report Revives Troubling Questions
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Sowell: Genes and Racism
- Starnes: Saudi National Questioned in Boston Attack was on Terror Watch List
- Sowell: Immigration Gambles
- Williams: Academic Cesspools
- Coulter: The Problem Isn't Just Illegal Immigration, It's Legal Immigration, Too
- Adams: Letters to a Young Progressive
- Hawkins: 20 Nasty, Weird and Sexist Liberal Cracks About Women
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Malkin: America's Insane Asylum for Jihadists, Hustlers and Frauds
- Malkin: A National Security History Lesson for Marco Rubio
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Parker: How Abortion Has Changed America
- Schlichter: Can Marco Rubio Save Marco Rubio From Himself?
- Ransom: The Dishonorable Liberal Order of Regulatory Scientists
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Kieffer: BENGHAZIGATE: Obama’s Secret Gun-Running Program
- Barone: Benghazi Report Revives Troubling Questions
- Mitchell: To Punch a Liberal
- DeHaven: Rubio Blames GOP for Government Dependency
- Calculations: The Myth of Michelle Obama's "Food Desert"
- Mitchell: Canada Wants to Join the Government Stupidity Contest
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Parker: How Abortion Has Changed America
- Schlichter: Can Marco Rubio Save Marco Rubio From Himself?
- Ransom: The Dishonorable Liberal Order of Regulatory Scientists
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Kieffer: BENGHAZIGATE: Obama’s Secret Gun-Running Program
- Barone: Benghazi Report Revives Troubling Questions
- Mitchell: To Punch a Liberal
- DeHaven: Rubio Blames GOP for Government Dependency
- Calculations: The Myth of Michelle Obama's "Food Desert"
- Mitchell: Canada Wants to Join the Government Stupidity Contest
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Parker: How Abortion Has Changed America
- Ransom: Liberals Suck at Math and Eyeballs
- Schlichter: Can Marco Rubio Save Marco Rubio From Himself?
- Ransom: The Dishonorable Liberal Order of Regulatory Scientists
- Giles: Jihad On Our Tax Dollars? Screw That.
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Hunter: Creating Monsters: Terrorism, Welfare and “Celebrating Diversity”
- Beauprez: All that Ammo
- Kieffer: BENGHAZIGATE: Obama’s Secret Gun-Running Program
- Barone: Benghazi Report Revives Troubling Questions
Tuesday, May 21 | 03:27 AM ET
- Parker: How Abortion Has Changed America
- Schlichter: Can Marco Rubio Save Marco Rubio From Himself?
- Ransom: The Dishonorable Liberal Order of Regulatory Scientists
- Bialosky: Now Obama Wants Your Pension
- Kieffer: BENGHAZIGATE: Obama’s Secret Gun-Running Program
- Barone: Benghazi Report Revives Troubling Questions
- Mitchell: To Punch a Liberal
- DeHaven: Rubio Blames GOP for Government Dependency
- Calculations: The Myth of Michelle Obama's "Food Desert"
- Mitchell: Canada Wants to Join the Government Stupidity Contest
- Quotes of the day Allahpundit 4 hours ago
- Awesome. Scammers faking disabilities to cut lines Jazz Shaw 5 hours ago
- Obama’s Morehouse address: The good, the bad, and the pot Mary Katharine Ham 6 hours ago
- “Experienced Democrats” whispering that it might be time for Holder to go Allahpundit 6 hours ago
- Obamacare supporter shocked that employers moving to bare bones coverage Jazz Shaw 8 hours ago
- New MSNBC theory: Maybe the IRS commissioner appointed by Bush targeted tea partiers because they’re a threat to the GOP Allahpundit 8 hours ago











What Will You Say Next Year, in Two Years, and in Five?