In response to:

The Borking of 'Zero Dark Thirty'

Matt65 Wrote: Feb 28, 2013 12:02 PM
I've personally been trapped underwater and feared drowning. It is terrifying. But while I don't like the use of waterboarding, there's no doubt it is an effective means of interrogation. As for accuracy, no one makes operational decisions based on a single confession. The information is always confirmed through other sources. As for the anti-Zero Dark Thirty statements from Hollywood elites, is anyone really surprised? They are not known for their integrity.
Mike4603 Wrote: Feb 28, 2013 2:08 PM
Who pays any attention to anything Ed Asner says, For gods sake he's selling solar panels!!!
PurpleStateBlueVote Wrote: Feb 28, 2013 12:11 PM
What makes you think "there's no doubt it is an effective means of interrogation"? The argument against it (any torture) being an effective means of interrogation states that under such duress the victim (yes, victim) will say anything. When you couple that with an interrogator who is convinced the victim has certain information to disclose, and will not stop until he receives that information, it becomes a recipe for confirming the interrogator's suspicions, regardless of whether they are true or not. In other words, if the victim really DOESN'T know what the interrogator seeks, or knows to be false something the interrogator seeks to have confirmed, it is virtually impossible to get this across to the interrogator.
AKFred1 Wrote: Feb 28, 2013 2:54 PM
purple

So you have experience in interrogations or how information is gleamed from captives. Please enlighten me with the techniques.
scrow Wrote: Feb 28, 2013 5:24 PM
Not if you make it clear to them that there will be secondary confirmation of their information.

Any form of incompetent interrogation will yield incompetent results, whether it be torture or gentle words.
t252 Wrote: Mar 02, 2013 7:46 PM
That's right purple, people have been tortured for thousands of years in war, for information, and no one ever realized they were getting the wrong information. tens of thousands tortured, and it took an anti-bush group of democrats to finally, after all these centuries, come to the conclusion that it didn't work.
If that is so, please tell me why soldiers are only given enough intel to accomplish their immediate mission, since everyone knows torture doesn't work?
All that tells me is the liberal democrats are as incompetent at torture as they are at everything else. Oh, one more thing - water boarding is not torture.

Weeks before the Oscars, Sony Pictures, the studio behind "Zero Dark Thirty," put out this statement: "We are outraged that any responsible member of the Academy would use their voting status in (the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences) as a platform to advance their own political agenda. The film should be judged free of partisanship. To punish an artist's right of expression is abhorrent. This community, more than any other, should know how reprehensible that is."

To what was Sony Pictures co-chair Amy Pascal referring?

"Zero Dark Thirty," directed by Kathryn Bigelow and written by Mark...

Thursday, May 23 | 01:06 PM ET
Thursday, May 23 | 01:06 PM ET
Thursday, May 23 | 01:06 PM ET
Thursday, May 23 | 01:06 PM ET