In response to:

How Liberals Argue: Food Stamps Stimulate the Economy

John C6 Wrote: Nov 29, 2012 3:47 PM
Gentle Readers, Most Food Stamp recipients are children, the disabled, or the infirm elderly. There are some who are able-bodied adults, who, sorry to say, have never worked a single day in their life, and there is some fraud, but overall, the program recipients are the intended beneficiaries. The question we could ask is this: If spending on Food Stamps is an ' economic stimulus ', then why not spend money on Defense? Wouldn't Defense Spending do the same? Democrats demand Defense Cuts and increased Welfare claiming increased Welfare is a ' stimulus '. This is a contradictory position. Sincerely, John Lepant Brighton CO
wtmoore1 Wrote: Nov 29, 2012 4:07 PM
I'm not sure I understand the premise of your complaint with Dems, but I'll take a crack at it.

You seem to be saying that Democrats claim food stamps are 'economic stimulus,' which means that Democrats claim that the stimulus to the economy would be a sufficient reason alone to enact food stamp programs--and I don't think many Democrats would take the logic that far. I think most would say that food stamp programs are justified by the need, especially poverty and hunger rates amongst children and the elderly, and the fact that it manifests in capital that is disposed of immediately at the retail level is an added benefit--because it stimulates the economy. But not many would argue that the sole, or even primary, purpose is stimulus.
Quix Wrote: Nov 29, 2012 3:57 PM
Please provide your souce. 47,000,000 on food stamps does not seem to me to align with your comment.

Every Thursday morning I go on the Jon Justice show in Southern Arizona. Today, I made a comment about the glorification of food stamps and apparently that sparked a deluge of calls like the one below in which the caller argues welfare stimulates the economy.

Considering Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi thinks the same way, I'm not surprised.

"It's the biggest bang for the buck."

Sunday, May 19 | 01:22 PM ET
Sunday, May 19 | 01:22 PM ET
Sunday, May 19 | 01:22 PM ET
Sunday, May 19 | 01:22 PM ET