The Atheist Response to Sandy Hook

Prager was only saying what an atheist would need to say to be consistent with their world view. Lack of internal consistency between claimed belief and what atheists would actually say by way of consolation was his point. Prager was not suggesting atheists must say his last paragraph just that it accurately sums up the atheistic world view and leaves them with nothing useful to say to the grieving. Well, I suppose they could say “I feel your pain” for what that is worth.