(Reuters) - A Cook County judge on Thursday dismissed charges against 92 people arrested last October during two anti-Wall Street Occupy demonstrations in Chicago and said a rarely applied city curfew law violated their constitutional right to free assembly.
Police arrested more than 300 people during the protests for violating a city ordinance when they did not leave a park near Lake Michigan when it closed at 11 p.m. Violation of a city ordinance was the lowest possible misdemeanor charge.
The demonstrations were held in Grant Park, which was the site of large protests against the Vietnam War during the Democratic Party's convention in Chicago in 1968. The area has been a gathering point since 1835, two years before the city was incorporated.
The demonstrators contended the curfew was unconstitutional because it acted as a blanket bar on all speech and was enforced arbitrarily against them. The city said it was applied regardless of speech and the demonstrators had other avenues in which they could communicate.
Cook County Court Judge Thomas Donnelly said the city has made "ad hoc exceptions to the curfew for permitted groups."
"Grant Park's history makes clear: it constitutes the quintessential public forum," Donnelly wrote.
Donnelly noted in a written ruling that the city arrested the demonstrators at the Grant Park Occupy rally, but none of the supporters of President Barack Obama at a victory rally that ran past curfew in the same park in 2008.
"Hopefully this sends a clear message to the city that they must better respect the First Amendment rights of protesters no matter what their message might be," Sarah Gelsomino, a People's Law Office attorney who represented the demonstrators.
Police arrested 173 people at a demonstration on October 16 and another 130 on October 23 for violating the city park curfew. Most had already accepted a deal to perform community service rather than take a conviction.
(Reporting by David Bailey; Editing by Mary Wisniewski and Jackie Frank)
Our Reversible Moral Coma
NY Cop Convicted; CA Cop Charged in Negligent Discharge Deaths
(VIDEO) PROOF POSITIVE. Ben Carson's Dishonesty Is Bone Deep | RedState
New Jersey Man Slays Child | Human Events
Flint’s Water Poisoned by Federal, State and Local Government Failures
'Can't imagine': Dana Perino and Ari Fleischer amazed by what's in these Hillary-related emails
Jake Tapper’s interview with the DNC Chair on superdelegates and the train wreck that followed