William Perry Pendley

When radical law school professors and administrators created the Forum for Academic and Institutional Rights (FAIR) to permit them to sue then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld anonymously to challenge the constitutionality of the Solomon Amendment, which seeks to ensure the ability of military recruiters to appear on campus, the Bush Administration responded quickly and aggressively. When FAIR filed a lawsuit in New Jersey federal district court, federal lawyers vigorously defended the constitutionality of the law, which, although enacted by overwhelming margins in both Houses of Congress in 1996, was not enforced until after September 11, 2001.

The district court denied FAIR’s motion for an injunction; however, a three judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, by 2-1, ruled that the Solomon Amendment was unconstitutional and barred its enforcement. Federal lawyers could have returned to the district court for a ruling on the merit; instead, denied the ability to seek en banc review at the Third Circuit—too many judges had recused themselves—they asked the Supreme Court to hear the case despite its preliminary footing. The Solomon Amendment is too important, they reasoned, to allow the preliminary injunction to stand, and perhaps to spread to other federal circuits, for the years necessary to take a ruling on the merits to the Supreme Court.

Arguments took place in December 2005 and it was at once clear that FAIR was going to take a beating notwithstanding that the nation’s top law schools and professors had filed friends of the court briefs in its behalf. Sure enough, in March 2006, the Court ruled 8-0; the Solomon Amendment is constitutional. One constitutional challenge remained; a Connecticut federal district court had ruled in favor of Yale Law School professors. Curiously, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit did not dismiss the case summarily by relying on the Supreme Court’s March ruling. Nonetheless, in September 2007, the Second Circuit ruled the professors’ claims either were “lacking in merit” or had been rejected by the Supreme Court.


William Perry Pendley

William Perry Pendley is President and Chief Legal Officer at the Mountain States Legal Foundation.

Be the first to read William Pendley's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.