Thomas Sowell

Some state universities are having smaller and smaller proportions of their costs paid for by the states, and some people are talking about the possibility of their ceasing to be state universities at all.

The University of Texas at Austin, for example, gets more money from student tuition than it gets from the state government. That's not counting how much money it gets from the federal government, from foundations, from alumni donations, from the earnings of its own endowment, and from other sources.

More than one-fourth of the students on this flagship campus of the University of Texas system have parents who make $100,000 a year and up. It is not immediately obvious why the average taxpayer should be subsidizing the education of these students, much less the research of their professors.

The image of a state university, as a place where those unable to afford a pricey private college can nevertheless get a good education, applies less and less to flagship universities like the University of Texas at Austin, the University of California at Berkeley, or the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor. These are places whose main output is research, not undergraduate education.

During my years as a tenured faculty member at UCLA, I never saw a junior faculty member whose contract was not renewed because he was not a good teacher. But I saw many who were terminated because their research was not of the quantity or quality that was expected -- regardless of how good they were at teaching. It was strictly publish or perish.

UCLA was not at all unique in this. It is common at both state and private universities for the "teacher of the year" award to be regarded by some as the kiss of death. That is because so many people who have received this award have also been terminated.

Good teaching takes up time -- in preparation for class and in student conferences -- which reduces the time available for research. A professor at the University of Michigan put it bluntly: "Every minute I spend in an undergraduate classroom is costing me money and prestige."

Parents and taxpayers may not understand what their state universities are doing, but those inside these institutions know all too well what pays off and what doesn't. Nor is there anything wrong with research in general, though much academic research is dubious. The real question is: What kinds of activities should take place in what kinds of institutions -- and at whose expense?

Thomas Sowell

Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institute and author of The Housing Boom and Bust.

Creators Syndicate