Terry Jeffrey

"You will see that as the individual's income rises they pick up a larger and larger share of the premium," said Romney. "And, ultimately, when they exceed 300 percent of the federal poverty level, they are able to pick up their entire premium ..."

"So, this is a plan," Romney said, "where people are able to get an insurance product they can afford -- $2.30 a week -- and as their income over their career goes up, they are able to get ongoing insurance with the same company."

But what happens if this person disdains the generosity of the royal "we" and still does not want insurance?

In Romney's plan, they would not be allowed that choice. In fact, even people unsubsidized by the royal "we" would no longer have that choice.

"To tell people in our society today that they have to go out and buy insurance would be unfair and wrong," Romney said. "Because right now, they don't have products they can afford. And if people are poor, they don't have any subsidy that they can rely on to help them get a product. So, it would be crazy to say to people, hey, you're (un)insured, you better go get it. They can't afford it.

"But once we put in place the reforms I am describing, with new affordable products as well as a subsidized product, where your premium can be as low as $2.30 a week, now everybody can get insurance," said Romney.

Romney then explained his offer you cannot refuse: "And that is, look, now that we have these products available for you, we want everybody to get insurance and you have responsibility of having insurance, and we are going to mandate that you have insurance."

So, did Romney's plan to insure the 7 percent who had been uninsured work?

In 2008-2009, two years after Romney signed his plan, 4.96 percent of the people in Massachusetts remained uninsured, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation. As of the first half of 2011, according to Gallup, 5.3 percent of the people in Massachusetts remained uninsured.

In exchange for upping the percentage of insured in Massachusetts by about 2 points -- from approximately 93 percent to approximately 95 percent -- Romney gave the state the power to order people to buy a product they did not want and put a Republican imprimatur on the idea that government should subsidize health insurance for families of four earning up to what the Heritage Foundation estimated was $60,432 in 2005 dollars.

"You may call this an individual mandate," Romney said at Heritage. "I don't. I call it the personal responsibility principle."


Terry Jeffrey

Terence P. Jeffrey is the editor-in-chief of CNSNews

Be the first to read Terence Jeffrey's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate


TOWNHALL MEDIA GROUP