Terry Jeffrey

The president's name was George Bush. He had just won a stunning victory in the Middle East, and his approval rating was soaring -- although some worried about his handling of the economy.

It is irresistible to compare the political prospects President George H.W. Bush faced 12 years ago with those his son faces today.

But don't dwell on similarities. The differences are the real story.

The first difference: Bush I polled better than his son does today. A March 1991 USA Today poll fixed Bush I's approval rating at 91 percent. Seventy-two percent said they would re-elect him. By contrast, an April 13 Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll fixed Bush II's approval rating at 71 percent. Fifty-two percent said they would re-elect him. Not bad -- but still 20 points behind his dad.

Yet, as Bush I learned, history's pages are crammed with wartime leaders, including Winston Churchill, whose popularity collapsed when the shooting stopped.

The good news for Bush II: Other differences between his father's situation and his own underscore his superior positioning.

Bush II has a solid Republican Party behind him. Bush I did not. Seven months before the Gulf War, he had dropped a bunker-buster on his own political base. In 1988, candidate Bush won the devotion of conservatives by declaring, "Read my lips: No new taxes." In June 1990, he betrayed that pledge by offering to negotiate "tax revenue increases" with Democratic leaders.

A month later, he nominated the liberal David Souter to the Supreme Court.

In swift, successive hammer blows, Bush II smashed up the Holy Grails of both economic and social conservatives. They never trusted him again.

Bush II's relationship with the Republican base reverses his father's. He has grown in their affection -- even though he has never been perfect on conservative issues, or (more to the point) pretended to be.

Bush II was elected promising to boost federal involvement in education, which conservatives consider ineffective and unconstitutional. He signed the First Amendment-busting McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Act. He has flirted with granting an amnesty to illegal aliens. But all the while he has shown fidelity to conservatives on the biggest domestic issues: He enacted a supply-side tax cut, he has called for another, and he has made excellent nominations to the appellate courts.

He heads toward an election year fighting the Democrats for tax cuts and conservative judges. Unless he pulls an unlikely about-face -- i.e., suddenly cutting a deal to raise taxes, or nominating another David Souter -- the entire Republican base will march jubilantly behind him all the way to the polls.


Terry Jeffrey

Terence P. Jeffrey is the editor-in-chief of CNSNews

Be the first to read Terence Jeffrey's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate