Jessica Lynch and Elizabeth Smart as portrayed on the small screen are appropriate heroines for our times (i.e., ratings month). Their stories stoop to the lowest common denominators of sensation, tawdry sentimentalism and phony innuendo, camouflaged with emotional color. We're supposed to be uplifted and inspired.
Saying that is not to criticize either of the young women in real life, but their stories as presented on the screen tell a tale of distortion and exploitation. The exploiters are not those who lived through the story but those who massaged it, manipulated it, pushed it and produced it, and the culture that relishes "reality drama" no matter how much bunk passes for fact.
Everyone's sympathies go out to Jessica Lynch, who did not ask to be held hostage to hero worship and does not consider herself a heroine. She suffered grievous physical wounds. Who can blame Mohammed Odeh Al-Rehaief, the Iraqi man responsible for her rescue, for selling his story?
But the television tale does not bear his name and it was made without Jessica's cooperation. She is merely a bit player to swell the action. It could have been called "An Iraqi to the Rescue," but who would have cared?
Jessica, a country girl from a town called Palestine in West Virginia, joined the Army to see the world. She had the bad luck to take a wrong turn at the wrong time. She was forced to face the enemy armed only with a gun choked by sand. Is anyone making money on her story contributing any of it to the families of the soldiers who died with her, making the story possible?
In an irony of these squalid times, Jessica had to share the screen on the same night with Elizabeth Smart. Elizabeth even wanted to play herself in the television movie. What could have been better than becoming a performer in your own "autobiography"?
Contemporary fame is often more real in performance than in a life actually lived. Many young Hollywood twinklers become images of others and never have to forge characters of their own. Elizabeth Smart's mother, as tiresome a backstage mother as there ever was, showed unexpected discretion by not allowing a tale of sexual molestation be told about her daughter. She would let Elizabeth do that later, if she chooses. And no doubt she will.
Rape is the most bankable event in our culture, more valuable than murder and a lot more valuable than mere mayhem. Jessica Lynch has no memory of being raped, doctors at the hospital insist they found no evidence at all that she ever was. But it's in her book.
Damage Control: Left Issues Slew of Statements After Execution Style Police Killings | Katie Pavlich
Tragedy: Murdered NYPD Police Officers Taken From Wives, Child Days Before Christmas | Katie Pavlich