The parents in Dover who are suing say that parents, not schools, should be responsible for a child's religious education.
This may work OK with kids who come from intact families. But in today's America, with high divorce rates, and where almost three of 10 babies are born to unwed mothers, this is becoming increasingly rare.
In inner-city black America, disrupted families are, unfortunately, the rule rather than the exception. Most black kids in inner-city schools come from single-parent homes.
The result is these kids come from directionless homes and go to directionless schools. Half wind up dropping out, and the ones who make it through graduate with eighth-grade reading skills.
However one chooses to rationalize how the black family got into such bad shape, we have now only the fact. And we have only the fact that black poverty and the black underclass will persist for another 50 years if black children do not get educated.
Value neutral, or as is more often the case, politically correct, government schools will never educate black children who live in social chaos.
Rather than trying to rationalize religion and morality back into public schools, the only reasonable approach in today's America is to fight government control of schools.
Allow parents to choose where to send their kids to school. Parents, not judges or bureaucrats, should decide whether to send their child to a school that teaches Intelligent Design.
And black kids should be given the opportunity to go to schools that are allowed to teach how to live as well as what to learn to get a job.
Star Parker is author of "Uncle Sam's Plantation: How Big Government Enslaves America's Poor and What We Can Do about It" and president of CURE, Coalition on Urban Renewal and Education, www.urbancure.org.