Ross Mackenzie

No one is arguing with the Constitution -- or about the constitutional and civil rights of Muslims. No one is saying Rauf and his Muslims have no right to put their Cordoba mosque near Ground Zero. Of course they have the right. What they lack is the wisdom, the sensitivity, the prudence. They know precisely what they're doing, and they obfuscate in clouds of a high-sounding and preening moralism their insensitivity to the feelings of Americans, New Yorkers, and family-members of those lost on 9/11.

Rauf the moderate is not a moralist?

Hard to say. Rauf won't disclose the lead financiers of his $100 million mosque, though they are rumored to be Saudi Arabia, a principal in the mosque-building (and madrassa-building) business, and Iran. (Interestingly, Nancy Pelosi, who has voiced few concerns about Rauf's financial backers, is adamant about learning who is financing the opponents of the Cordoba victory mosque.)

Yet Rauf has said a number of immoderate things atypical of your run-of-the-mill moralist. Such as: (a) 9/11 was a justifiable expression against American-caused Muslim grievance, and (b) moving the mosque to a different site would invite a barrage of negative press in Muslim countries (where contempt for America already runs deep). Also (c) Rauf has declined to term Hamas a terrorist group, contrary to the determination of the U.S. State Department.

So where does all this leave the discussion?

First, in opposing the Cordoba mosque at the Ground Zero location, two-thirds of the American people (as recorded by the pollsters) are not naive, never mind that Rauf and his leftist supporters want their sentiments over-ridden and the mosque built next year -- the year of those two very big Islamic anniversaries, 1,300th and 10th.

Second, Manhattan already boasts Muslim mosques, but the politicized (Johns Hopkins' Fouad Ajami uses the word weaponized) faith of Islam does not need yet another at Ground Zero. The American people are right to oppose it there, and the operative truth is that it likely won't ever be built there.

Won't be built there? Why?

Because, as The Wall Street Journal's Dorothy Rabinowitz has written, "Liberal piety may have met its match in the raw memory of 9/11, and in citizens who have come to know pure demagoguery when they hear it."

New York's first-responders, their ranks so ravaged on 9/11, and hard-hat laborers who spent so much time picking up the pieces, will exercise their own constitutional rights. Reflecting the overwhelming sentiment of the national populace, they'll put up picket lines. Any efforts to cross them could prove as unpretty as the collapsing leftism that encouraged the confrontations. The mosque won't happen.


Ross Mackenzie

Ross Mackenzie lives with his wife and Labrador retriever in the woods west of Richmond, Virginia. They have two grown sons, both Naval officers.

Be the first to read Ross Mackenzie's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.