A League of Her Own

Two years on, it might be tough to find the original owner, but you should try -- to clear your conscience and set an example for your kids. Put yourself in the owner's (chewed-up and drooled-upon) shoes. Wouldn't you want your dog back, even now? Wouldn't you at least want to know that your dog is happy and healthy? (And worth a cool $1,500 on the black market?)

It would be sad to part with the dog but worse to remain passive now that you know its origins (and worse still to pal around with your friend now that you know his values). And remember that every shelter houses wonderful dogs in need of homes.

UPDATE: M.S. still has the dog but plans to put up fliers soon.