Paul Jacob

Back in college, decades ago, my political theory professor regaled his students with stories of the brilliant political analyses and insights of his favorite European socialist intellectuals. Abhorring socialism, I began to better appreciate my Mother’s oft-repeated challenge: “If everyone else jumps off a cliff, are you going to jump, too?”

Ideas are wise or foolish, however, without regard to national origin. Americans can and have learned great concepts from folks in Europe and Asia and Africa. It’s called paying attention. We Homo sapiens do have an uncanny knack for imitation.

Michelle Malkin

Take Switzerland. The Swiss Confederation has more than 150 years of experience with citizens enacting or rejecting laws through initiative and referendum. It thus offers the world a worthwhile example of participatory democracy. Odd that more countries haven’t flat-out ripped off the idea for their own benefit.

Of course, empowering voters offers distinct advantages for the average person. Not so for the political elite. For them, when it comes to citizen power, less is more.

That’s why it is worth taking note of the new European Citizens’ Initiative (ECI), brought to life through the European Union’s Lisbon Treaty. This foray into citizen engagement is far, far tamer than the Swiss model of voter initiative and referendum — or the citizen initiative process at work in 24 of these United States.

In fact, while dubbed “direct democracy,” the ECI seems anything but direct.

It better resembles a suggestion box than the familiar-to-the-Swiss (and us) initiative. To propose a measure through the ECI, more than a million Europeans representing a significant percentage of citizens in at least one-third of EU countries must sign a petition. This is a serious hurdle, though the requirement is not nearly as difficult as the signature levels that must be met in most states in order to qualify a ballot measure.

Moreover, even if the petition reaches the necessary signature threshold, and is found to be an area of governance that can be properly addressed by the EU, the ECI will not result in a vote of the people throughout the Union. Nor does an ECI require the representative bodies of the European Union to represent the very sentiments of those petitioning by taking any specific action in light of a million citizens petitioning their transnational government.


Paul Jacob

Paul Jacob is President of Citizens in Charge Foundation and Citizens in Charge. His daily Common Sense commentary appears on the Web and via e-mail.
 



TOWNHALL MEDIA GROUP