Paul Jacob

So they seek to tightly regulate the private use of toxin detection devices. Falkenrath warned New York City’s Public Safety Committee, headed by Peter Vallone Jr., that unregulated private deployment of toxin detection devices could lead to false alarms that could trigger “massive emergency response with all sorts of problems.” Falkenrath proposed an overarching plan, with licensed users legally obligated to inform special units in case of positive readings, yadda, yadda, yadda.

Now, the disturbing thing about this is not that the government wanted to get involved. Protection, after all, should be government’s number one issue, and protection from terrorism high on that agenda. The disturbing thing is the how of it; there were other ways of approaching the issue.

The city government could have approached the problems associated with detecting toxins not as a regulator, but as an organization that can add value to each individual’s personal and family and business security.

How? Instead of demanding that detectors be licensed, the city could offer to check detectors for a fee. And provide classes on how to use them, and how to communicate with various divisions of the government. In general, see the population not as cattle to be herded, but as both clients to serve and colleagues to co-operate with.

But regulation comes just so much quicker to certain types of mind, I guess.

Not surprisingly, when the folk who do most of today’s testing became alarmed, the commissioner insisted — against all current evidence — that “unless the police can determine who gets to look for nasty stuff floating in the air, the city would be paralyzed by fear.”

At a public meeting it was noted that after 9/11, when the EPA said the air in the neighborhoods surrounding Ground Zero was safe, it was privately held detectors that proved the EPA wrong. The commissioner did a little hemming and hawing.

But when asked if the city really had to put unlicensed detector users in jail, the bozo said yes.

Not surprisingly, the feds are partly to blame for this. They are the ones who pushed Falkenrath and the city to “investigate” the “problem” of unlicensed toxin detectors. Hint hint.

And yet the top-of-the-line toxin detectors — technology so expensive we can’t expect individuals or businesses to buy them — are still not being distributed around the country with anything like all necessary haste, despite ballooning budgets in Homeland Security. (Perhaps the bureaucrats there are still spending money on conferences in Hawaii.)

While we worry about furiners coming to our shores to spew germs and poisons, visiting anthropologists might better explain our politicians’ over-reactions than we can ourselves. They might note how fear of panic is itself a kind of panic. And how useful it is to maintain the herd.

Remember: Fear is the great weapon of tyrants everywhere, their usual excuse to undermine freedom.

Sometimes — indeed, even in this case — we have the most to fear not from our enemies but from our leaders cleverly pushing fear of fear itself.

Paul Jacob

Paul Jacob is President of Citizens in Charge Foundation and Citizens in Charge. His daily Common Sense commentary appears on the Web and via e-mail.