Deep in the belly of this whale, I feel not submerged but lifted by an old
feeling. I recognize it from my wasted youth as a wannabe historian, when I
was certain that the next file I opened in some presidential library would
produce the magic slip of paper, the telltale photograph, the confidential
memo that would reveal all. There was no telling what one might find in one
of those dusty cartons.
As a graduate student researching the national political ambitions of Huey
Long, I visited the old Roosevelt mansion at Hyde Park, N.Y., and came
across an exchange of memos between FDR and his campaign manager, James
Aloysius Farley, about the possibility of the Kingfish's running for
president in 1936.
Farley wasn't at all concerned. FDR was-another confirmation of his
political astuteness. But he needn't have worried; Huey was shot down in
Louisiana's state Capitol in September of '35. We'll never know how well he
would have done as a presidential candidate, but he could scarcely have
fared any worse than the Republican candidate that year-hapless Alf Landon,
who found himself up against The Great Communicator of his era.
Here in the innards of the Clinton Library, the past towers over us. The
library's more than hospitable director, David Alsobrook, shows us the
mountains of still undigested boxes and crates-and a system of compact
shelving that squeezes reams of historical documents into the smallest
space, like some giant accordion. Who knows what one might find tucked away
here?
Even if the hope of finding the one clue that explains everything is never
fulfilled, there is nothing quite like the search for it. We could have been
in the final scene of "Citizen Kane," the classic film modeled on the life
and larger-than-life times of William Randolph Hearst, searching through the
detritus of history in the cavernous bowels of Charles Foster Kane's
pharaonic mansion, hoping to discover the significance of his last,
enigmatic word: Rosebud.
History can be one long search for a moment of insight. In Robert Penn
Warren's "All the King's Men," Jack Burden finally tracks down the last
letter from Mortimer L. Littlepaugh, Esq., which reveals all. "For nothing
is lost, nothing is ever lost," says Jack.
But finding the key to it all isn't easy. There are many names for this
hunt: research, obsession, calling and there are few better places to
pursue it than deep inside a presidential library, or in an old Mobil gas
station stranded in time.