Richard Paey is a husband, a father, and an Ivy-league educated lawyer. Some years ago, he suffered a catastrophic auto accident that required a number of surgical procedures. Because one of those procedures was badly botched he now suffers from debilitating and excruciating pain.
Richard is now serving a 25-year mandatory minimum sentence in a Florida prison. This is because he did, in fact, violate the law in order to obtain pain medication. In fact, he filled prescriptions for 700 oxycodone pills and large quantities of other pain relief medications within a period of just 36 days.
The evidence that Paey tampered with the prescriptions is, in my opinion, conclusive. But I have yet to see any evidence that Paey intended to do anything else with the medicine. That is why the 25-year sentence is such a tough pill to swallow for many observers, whether liberal, conservative, or libertarian.
After the state charged and convicted Paey under a drug trafficking law, he appealed on the basis of Cruel and Unusual Punishment. Two members of a three-member panel voted to uphold Paey's sentence because, quite simply, there was no legal error. A very bad law was followed properly – at least in the court of law.
But now it is time to move Paey’s case into the court of public opinion. The executive branch can and should be appealed to for a pardon given the futility of Paey’s legal case.
It may be difficult for many to believe that Paey – who uses a wheelchair and has attempted suicide twice – really filled prescriptions for 700 pills in seven weeks merely for personal use. But that raises fundamental questions about the law used to secure Paey’s conviction.
For example, most would agree that it makes sense to assume a person with no previous history of medical dependence is a drug dealer based merely on circumstantial evidence of the possession of hundreds of illegally obtained narcotic pills. But, given the highly addictive nature of the pills, should the law not require direct evidence when the suspect has a history of medical drug dependence?
When I hear the story of Richard Paey sitting in prison hooked to a morphine pump that is currently providing him with a dose stronger than the medication he was convicted of obtaining illegally, I am reminded of something that once happened to me. In fact, it happened just a few months ago.
Latest: Germanwings Co-Pilot Suffered From "Illness," Ripped Up "Sick Notes" Day of Crash | Daniel Doherty