Michael Gerson

This strategy may succeed because Republicans are genuinely divided. One bloc -- the faction of the serious -- is led by Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis., author of the 2012 House Republican budget. Few details of that document are surprising, but the cumulative effect is comprehensive and impressive. House Republicans propose major tax reform, including lower top rates, a broadened tax base and the closing of loopholes. The plan sets hard spending caps and adopts a number of recommendations by the president's fiscal commission, which were largely ignored by the president himself. Ryan's proposal takes on corporate welfare and farm subsidies, consolidates job-training programs and includes welfare and litigation reforms. Most importantly, Ryan begins the Medicare debate in earnest, proposing a system of means-tested premium supports -- taking seriously the challenge of 80 million baby boomers beginning to make their way into the system. Unlike his more libertarian colleagues, Ryan makes the case that entitlement reform, properly designed, can actually strengthen the social safety net for the poorest.

The less-than-serious faction of the Republican Party is intent on squeezing more savings out of the 2011 budget or pursuing a government shutdown as an end in itself. Some of this bloc is composed of House freshmen, who share the unrealistic expectations of the tea party base -- the undoing of modern government by one-half of one branch of that government. Others are more senior members of the Republican caucus -- representatives such as Mike Pence and Michele Bachmann -- who seek to raise their profiles by establishing themselves as rebel leaders.

Even by the most exacting conservative standards, the contrast of ambition and sophistication should be clear. Ryan Republicans are talking about trillions in eventual entitlement savings that would release America from perpetual debt and allow some room for future discretionary spending. They are proposing a series of broad structural reforms, each of which will be a plank in the 2012 Republican platform. Pence Republicans seek billions in savings achieved through a strategy that, in 1995, helped rescue the Clinton presidency. Their policy platform shows all the creativity and strategic positioning of a stop sign.

Boehner's task is to convince House Republicans to take a good deal for the rest of the year and focus on next year's battle over the Ryan budget. This fight will be considerably more difficult -- and dramatically more consequential.


Michael Gerson

Michael Gerson writes a twice-weekly column for The Post on issues that include politics, global health, development, religion and foreign policy. Michael Gerson is the author of the book "Heroic Conservatism" and a contributor to Newsweek magazine.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Michael Gerson's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.