With lots of media specials on tap this month as the first anniversary of the Katrina disaster approaches, it's time for an inoculation against some of the propaganda that will arise.
First, we'll hear TV personalities yakking about the unprecedented nature of the New Orleans calamity. Hmm -- an earthquake nearly 4,000 years ago brought the Minoan civilization on Crete to an end. An earthquake and tidal wave destroyed the Greek city of Helike in 373 B.C. Medieval disasters destroyed cities such as Dunwich, England, and Rungholt, Germany. The 1755 Lisbon earthquake became a propagandistic windfall for Voltaire.
Second, we'll hear that the media response to Katrina was unprecedented. Not so: A decade ago the National Academy of Public Administration expressed concern about the "CNN Syndrome." Disaster and emergencies provide dramatic news. The media pressure reluctant local and state leaders to "ask for federal help," presidents to dispatch such help and representatives and senators to demand it on behalf of their constituents. Similar things happened two millennia ago: When Romans heard that Vesuvius had exploded, they clamored for relief to be sent, and Emperor Titus complied.
Third and most important, we'll be told that the federal government should protect everyone against disaster. That's the truly dangerous conclusion, because one of our problems now is that governmental policies normalize disaster. Just as insurance now covers regular dental checkups, disaster designation (which brings federal money) now covers unsurprising events like wintry blizzards.
Here are a few stats: The first president to take office with the power to issue a declaration of disaster, Dwight Eisenhower, issued 107 such declarations during his eight years in office, an average of 13 per year. That rose to an annual average of 18 during the Kennedy/Johnson years and more than doubled to an average of 37 during the Nixon/Ford administrations.
The numbers then stayed relatively steady until 1993, but Bill Clinton more than doubled the total to 88. And George W. Bush, even more promiscuous in his declarations, averaged 139 annually during his first five years in office, or one catastrophe every 2.6 days.
CNN's Lemon Battles Rapper Over Ferguson--Let's "World Run By White Supremacy" Comment Slide | Greg Hengler