Marvin Olasky

Where's the ACLU? This co-mingling of government and religious resources must stop! Church groups, asked by local and state officials to take charge of feeding programs at government shelters like the George R. Brown Convention Center in Houston, also held worship services and passed out Bibles. Pastors prayed with evacuees, offering spiritual as well as material help. The horror!

 Where is the press vigilance? Instead of exposing this blatant attempt to destroy the separation of church and state, reporters quoted New Orleans evacuees such as Dorothy Lewis welcoming the Christian service because she (obviously with false consciousness) believed that God saved her family: "I can't go to sleep for thanking him. I wake up in the morning thanking him."

 Reporters uncritically quoted Protestant minister William Lawson telling the evacuees -- in a government building! -- "God hasn't forgotten you, no more than he had forgotten Job."

 Here's why the usual critics are generally silent: Christians are the Dirty Harrys of social service in today's America. The 1971 film "Dirty Harry" starred Clint Eastwood as a San Francisco cop hated by the liberal mayor but called upon when the going gets rough. In the movie, the Eastwood character gains his nickname because he takes on the most difficult tasks the city can offer. "Now you know why they call me 'Dirty Harry,'" he tells his partner after heroically saving one person from death: "Every dirty job that comes along."

 Many people, including Muslims and atheists, are getting their hands dirty in post-Katrina help. So are government and nonprofit professionals. But everyone knows that church groups are key.

 Remember the insurance company commercials in which the family provider is suddenly gone, leaving a ghostly frame where the photo once was? That would be our situation if strict church-state separationists had their way and Christians were not able to offer material and spiritual help in public spaces, sometimes with a piggybacking of resources.

 In short, when a Katrina crisis occurs, our "separation of church and state" turns into a marriage, with government and religious entities linked in providing aid to victims. Is that a crime? Not constitutionally.

 Here's one quick history lesson already familiar to some: The First Amendment opposes any "establishment of religion," but it does not advocate "separation of church and state." Thomas Jefferson wanted separation, but that was just Long Tom giving his opinion in an 1802 letter -- and what worried many folks then is no longer on the table.

Marvin Olasky

Marvin Olasky is editor-in-chief of the national news magazine World. For additional commentary by Marvin Olasky, visit
Be the first to read Marvin Olasky's column. Sign up today and receive delivered each morning to your inbox.