Someone like, say, Christopher Reeve?
The disabled actor recently joined with seven scientists to sue the Bush administration for causing "irreparable harm" for refusing to rubber stamp President Clinton's last-minute creative word search around the law banning federal funding for research on human embryos. The National Institutes of Health were all set to hand out the first set of grants when the phone call came from Health and Human Services, saying Bush wanted to review the newly eased regulations, saving us for the moment from a new class of taxpayer-financed itsy-bitsy humans free to be experimented on and consumed.
The stakes are high because so-called stem cells -- human cells not yet differentiated into specific organs -- are among the most promising sources of new treatments for disorders from Parkinson's to diabetes. As a diabetic, I should be pleased, but as a mother I'm appalled. Mothers, of course, are people in the human creation business, first physically and then in other ways. Let's just say I don't like the competition.
But the juggernaut of progress is not easy to stop, especially given the mounting brigade of public voices trying to convince Congress and the rest of us that to find the new fountain of eternal youth, or at least health, we have no choice but to eat our own young.
Maybe, maybe not. In the latest issue of the new American Spectator (look for the half-naked supermodel on the cover), Scott Gottlieb, a physician, adviser to the British Medical Journal and author of a new biotech newsletter about to be launched by Gilder Publishing, points out that venture capital markets are telling a very different story: Venture capitalists, he says, are generally better than government bureaucrats (even ones with Ph.D.s) or (gasp) journalists at predicting what technology is about to bear fruit. And venture capitalist money is betting heavily that stem cells from adults, not embryos, are going to be the cure for what ails us.
Maggie Gallagher is a nationally syndicated columnist, a leading voice in the new marriage movement and co-author of The Case for Marriage: Why Married People Are Happier, Healthier, and Better Off Financially.