For many high school seniors around the country, there was no Graduation Day this year. Despite good attendance and, in some instances, decent grades, thousands of high school seniors failed to pass mandatory state graduation exams implemented over the last decade to improve standards in education. Nearly half of all states now require, or are in the process of implementing, graduation tests to ensure that students who have been passed from grade to grade actually learned basic skills during their 12 years of public education.
Now, some policymakers and politicians -- not to mention the affected students and their parents -- are crying foul. In Florida, black activists have even called for a boycott of the state unless Gov. Jeb Bush reverses the requirement that students pass a state exam before they receive a diploma.
So who's right -- those who claim the tests prevent worthy seniors from receiving a diploma to which they're entitled, or those who argue that without some objective measure of what students have actually learned, a high school diploma isn't worth the paper it's printed on?
Rene Martinez, who will have to pass the California Exit Exam next year if he is to graduate from Roosevelt High School in East Los Angeles, says the test is not only unfair, "it makes me feel dumb," he told The Los Angeles Times last month. "It makes me feel like I should know all of this stuff, but I don't," he said, complaining of overcrowding at his school and poorly trained teachers. Only 22 percent of low-income California seniors passed the math test last year, the Times reported.
Robyn Collins, a high school senior from Sparks, Nevada, has maintained a 3.0 ("B") average but can't pass the state's math test required for graduation, even though she has taken it five times. "I'm not a stupid kid," Collins told The Washington Post recently. "It is just that in my opinion, the stuff on the test doesn't equate to anything that I've learned in school."
Students like Martinez and Collins are right to be angry -- but the tests aren't the problem. Most states require students to demonstrate only rudimentary knowledge of high school math, language arts, science and social studies in order to graduate. In some states, a student can "pass" the test by answering less than half the questions correctly, and virtually all states allow students multiple attempts to take the tests.
Linda Chavez is chairman of the Center for Equal Opportunity and author of Betrayal: How Union Bosses Shake Down Their Members and Corrupt American Politics .
Be the first to read Linda Chavez's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.
Student Paper Mocks Terrorists, University Warns Not to Disrupt 'Cultural Harmony' | Sarah Jean Seman