"There but for the grace of God go I." The phrase is usually a cautionary note. My neighbor's blunder could have been mine. My co-worker's illness could easily be my affliction. I ought to count my blessings. But the flipside of the phrase is pregnant with promise, and many Americans felt it when they learned that radio-broadcaster phenom Rush Limbaugh, who marks his 20th year "of broadcast excellence" this summer, is making media history with a new $400 million contract.
Sure, many right-wingers were happy just to know that "El Rushbo" is making more than Katie Couric. "That could be me one day," many surmise upon hearing news like that. With a little grace and hard work, maybe that kind of great success could be mine. Someday, that could be my son, if I teach him right. That sentiment -- an appreciation of what's possible in America, land of the free, which includes a free market -- is at the heart of the nonhardcore-Left reaction to the news.
There were, of course, complaints from the usual quarters. Ralph Nader took the occasion as an attention-grabbing opportunity, excoriating Rush with his keyboard as "the Kingboy of corporatist radio." On the Daily Kos Web site, as the news was breaking, one commentator declared, "the right has just bankrolled an eight-year radical right-radio attack on the presidency of Barack Obama." Besides ridicule and ill will, there was a lot of victory-declaring on the left-wing blogosphere and other media outlets, where the news wasn't taken as an acknowledgement of success and business acumen, but the Right conceding defeat: They'll need Limbaugh's voice because it will be all Left, all the time leading the White House and Congress come Jan. 20, was the premature declaration of victory.
That may happen, but I'm not giving up the fight yet. Heaven knows, Limbaugh goes on air nearly every day urging conservatives not to concede, but to fight; to focus on not just the White House but congressional seats this coming November, and battles long after. The host may not be a fan of John McCain, but he sees the existential threats American and human dignity face today and tomorrow.
As an Army lieutenant e-mailed me about the Limbaugh news, "Count me as one who is ecstatic about Rush Limbaugh and his big contract. I admit to being jealous, but in a positive way, since I know I have never deserved the kind of money he can generate. I hope he lives to be a hundred and gets more money every year until he checks out of the net. Anybody who begrudges his success has the right to see if they can do what he does better than he and knock him off his perch as the best radio entertainer around. Nobody so far even comes close; certainly no liberal or moderate."
This is how Americans tend to react. A recent Pew poll found that "being wealthy" is far from the top priority of Americans -- things like "having enough time to do things you want to do," "being successful in a career" and "having children." "Being married" rated in the top 50 percent, while "being wealthy" rates a 13 percent. Even though it's not the be-all, end-all for Americans to be rich, they are optimistic they could be and will be -- having that motivational hope, even when probably not entirely realistic. One 2000 Time magazine survey had 20 percent of Americans polled optimistic that they would someday be in the top 1 percent of American earners.
That was bad news for Democratic presidential nominee Al Gore in 2000, who attacked the top 1 percent. It's why McCain doesn't help himself with conservatives or the wide swath of American voters when he rails against executive pay, as he tends to. He's adapted Democratic rhetoric. While the Left tends to use "us and them" as part of their electoral strategy -- making Americans feel like victims who need to be saved by the government -- conservatives tend to try to capture the optimistic imaginations of Americans.
In this summer of high gas prices, imagine if McCain could talk about American exceptionalism, and, for example, embrace the opportunity that our discovery-spirit can present if we were to explore new drilling options in Alaska.
I don't know whether McCain will. I know he could if he wanted to. The Arizona senator and former prisoner of war has an inspiring personal story of national service and country "love," as a recent campaign commercial put it. I do know that Limbaugh inspires such things by words and example -- as one who has worked hard, fallen and gotten up again, making clear that we're all human, living in a country where the possibilities are endless. Excessive regulation, overbearing taxation, demagoguing about what Europe thinks about us -- these burdens and distractions hurt the civic morale and make the dream harder to achieve. Instead of patronizing, paternalistic governing by bureaucracy, if whoever takes the oath of office in January wants to protect and defend the Constitution, and let us otherwise live free in this great country full of citizens on the Left and Right, we'll be in good shape to keep dreaming.
As Netroots Nation Drinks Up Democrat Kool-Aid, AFL-CIO Warns This Could Be A 'Powerful' GOP Year | Matt Vespa
New Obama Executive Action Plan on Amnesty: Bring Kids to U.S. Directly From Central America | Katie Pavlich