During my orientation, the risks (known and unknown) were underplayed (just expect "really bad PMS," we were told) and contrasted with a hopeful spin -- the great contribution a young woman can make to an infertile couple's life. Judy Norsigian, executive director of the old-school feminist group Our Bodies, Our Selves, told a U.S. Senate committee in 2002: "Media coverage of human embryo cloning research has largely focused on its therapeutic potential, neglecting the technology's dependence on the thousands, if not millions, of women who must undergo the substantial health risks associated with harvesting their eggs."
Unfortunately, though, few feminists are rushing to join the likes of Norsigian. In reference to restricting the egg market in California, an official from the American Fertility Association recently told a reporter: "I get concerned when some women's groups say, 'Oh, no, we have to make these decisions for women.'" But how fair is the choice these women are being offered when they don't know what they're getting into, the benefits are overhyped, and they really need the money? And as we slip deeper into this brave new world of cloning, unprecedented numbers of eggs -- and women -- will be needed. Even the failed, fraudulent South Korean cloning experiment required hundreds of eggs. As Robert P. George, a member of the president's bioethics council, and Eric Cohen, editor of The New Atlantis, recently wrote: "For this research to proceed beyond South Korea's failed attempts, whether in Seoul or at Stanford, many thousands and perhaps millions of women would need to become egg donors -- or (as some say) egg mercenaries. No responsible doctor would allow his patient to undergo such risks and burdens simply to aid a speculative project of research, no matter how altruistic the aims. And no decent society would countenance the buying and selling of human eggs on the open market."
Of course, for those who (like me) oppose human cloning on more than the ground of exploitation, there's more at stake and a long battle ahead. But for now, when the cloning debate is such a mess that few people even know what they're talking about -- or voting on -- a creative coalition between pro-lifers and feminists is a golden egg to embrace. Without it, a lot more states than Missouri will soon be vying for the title of the Clone-Me State.
Son of Hamas Founder Defends Fight Against Terror: "Israel is Doing Them the Biggest Favor" | Katie Pavlich