Jonah Goldberg

Sharpton intended his speech to be an answer, but it turned out not to be an honest one. After a stem-winder of a peroration on the long struggle by blacks for civil rights and the usual mythologizing about the Florida recount, Sharpton stared straight into the camera and declared with a boom: "This [black] vote can't be bargained away. This vote can't be given away. Mr. President, in all due respect, Mr. President, read my lips: Our vote is not for sale."

The audience exploded at what was arguably the best sound bite of the convention.

So here's my problem: With all due respect, this is a crock. If Sharpton means to say that Republicans are trying to bribe blacks into giving up their right to vote - as the text seemingly suggests - then he's still the deceitful demagogue he was in the 1980s. There's no evidence Republicans tried, or even thought of, anything of the sort.

And, if Sharpton means to say that Democratic votes can't be bought through the usual pandering, graft and pork common to Democratic (and, alas, Republican) politicking, then he's either a fool or a liar. I don't just mean the infamous "walking around money" given to black preachers in the inner cities, but also the jobs, set-asides and quotas the Democratic Party reserves for blacks and other minorities. It is simply a fact that black votes are "bought" with a quid pro quo of Democratic support for issues blacks support. The same goes for Hispanics, Jews, feminists, and so forth.

And, to a certain extent this is as it should be. Politicians tend to reward their supporters and vice versa.

What is so disturbing about Sharpton's "Our vote is not for sale!" exclamation is the suggestion that it doesn't matter what Republicans do when it comes to the black vote. Bush's Urban League speech was not an attempt to tempt blacks into a Faustian bargain whereby blacks would sell their franchise. It was an attempt to show black voters that they aren't getting as much value for their political currency as they should. In Sharpton's formulation, President Bush could adopt the entire agenda of the Congressional Black Caucus - including "reparations," the ultimate political bribery - and blacks would stick with the Democrats.

This bigotry is twofold. First, Sharpton believes that Republicans are irredeemable enemies and, second, that blacks are incapable of seeing their interests as distinct from the Democrats. In effect, both Republicans and Democrats, according to Sharpton, are "born that way." What's worse than Sharpton's bigotry, though, is his bullying of blacks who might disagree with him. He's still the street thug he always was, just with better speechwriters - not that the Democratic Establishment cares if his speeches are well-written.


Jonah Goldberg

Jonah Goldberg is editor-at-large of National Review Online,and the author of the forthcoming book The Tyranny of Clichés. You can reach him via Twitter @JonahNRO.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Jonah Goldberg's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.