Imagine 300 Democrats in the House, 75 in the Senate, and a Democratic President for 10-12 years -- at least. In other words, the Democrats would be able to make their wildest dreams law and stack the Supreme Court with liberal judges.
Then finally, at long last, the Republican Party goes into the dust heap of history and the new purer third party rises up, phoenix-like from the ashes to take its place. Then, everything would be right with the world!
Well, not exactly.
First of all, setting aside the possibility that the Democrats would rig the rules of the game to make it all but impossible for an opposing party to get back into power -- given how radical the Democrats have become, the country would likely never recover from a decade of their mismanagement. Imagine becoming captain of the Titanic right after it hit the iceberg -- and then having the ship hit by a meteor. That's what it would be like after giving people like Barney Frank, Nancy Pelosi, and Barack Obama a full decade to try to turn the United States into a sunnier, happier version of the Soviet Union.
Well, at least, bad as it would be, we'd have a real conservative party back in charge for the long haul, right?
Well, not exactly.
Here's the one that will really infuriate the third party diehards: given time, the exact same people who are ruining the Republican Party would move over to the third party and ruin it, too. The inside-the-Beltway snobs, the squishes, the elitists, the country club Republicans, the our "conservatism" can be bought for the right price crowd -- if people can't figure out how to deal with them in the Republican Party, what makes anyone think they can be dealt with in a third party?
Sure, the Libertarian Party, Constitution Party, Green Party, etc. are much purer than the Republican and Democratic parties -- but there's a reason for that: they're not in power. They don't have a leech class that just wants to keep their cushy jobs. They don't get to hand out earmarks that indirectly put hundreds of thousands of dollars into the pockets of their families, friends, and political allies. They don't have to take electoral considerations into their policy positions because they don't ever get elected to anything. It's easy to be pure when you're on the outside looking in. When you have skin in the game and doing the right, but unpopular thing may cost you the job of a lifetime -- judging by what goes on in Congress, most people's moral courage goes out the window. That's not because of what party they're in; it's because of human nature. A third party isn't going to change that any more than communism suddenly makes everyone care as much about their neighbor down the street as they do their own family. That's why a viable third party, even if it were to exist, wouldn't solve anything.
Healthcare Solutions Begin with Innovators in Tennessee, Not Bureaucrats in Washington, DC | Congressman Marsha Blackburn