Jacob Sullum

Ernie and Pat Bechler, who testified at the recent congressional hearings on ephedra, blame the herbal stimulant for the death of their son, Baltimore Orioles pitcher Steve Bechler, during spring training last February. So does Bechler's widow, who has filed a lawsuit seeking $600 million in damages from the manufacturer and distributor of Xenadrine, an ephedra-based diet aid found in the 23-year-old baseball player's locker.

As one of Bechler's teammates put it, "Someone has to be held responsible for a young kid dying like that." But the rush to condemn ephedra, which the Food and Drug Administration and members of Congress have threatened to ban, is not justified by the evidence.

Bechler, who died of heatstroke, was overweight, had high blood pressure and abnormal liver function, and was exercising hard in hot, humid Florida weather to which he was not acclimated. Broward County Medical Examiner Joshua Perper concluded that "the toxicity of ephedra played a significant role in the death of Mr. Bechler, although it's impossible to define mathematically the contribution of each one of the factors in his unfortunate death due to heatstroke."

Perper added, "I am not saying (ephedra) was the triggering factor, because I cannot identify the triggering factor. You have here a constellation of factors working together."

But if ephedra was not "the triggering factor," it's possible that Bechler would still be dead even if he hadn't consumed the stimulant. That was the conclusion reached by the renowned forensic pathologist Michael Baden, whom Xenadrine's manufacturer asked to review the case.

"The coincidental toxicologic finding of ephedrine, which is not known to produce heat stroke, in my opinion should not have been linked to the death by the medical examiner," Baden wrote in a letter to the House committee that heard testimony from Bechler's parents. "It is my opinion, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty, . . . that Xenadrine did not cause or contribute to Mr. Bechler's death."

The Bechler case illustrates the peril of leaping to conclusions when someone dies after consuming an ephedra product. News reports frequently assert that "more than 100 deaths" have been "linked" to ephedra. Yet a RAND Corporation study of all the "adverse event" reports in the FDA's files and in the medical literature that were available as of September 30 found only two fatalities where there was an attempt to rule out other factors.


Jacob Sullum

Jacob Sullum is a senior editor at Reason magazine and a contributing columnist on Townhall.com.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Jacob Sullum's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate