Jack Kemp

After I went on TV last week answering former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich's attack on Secretary of State Colin Powell and the State Department, some folks accused me of piling on my old friend, Newt. I humbly disagree. Gingrich was so far off base even Bill Buckley said he overdid it. Let me explain why I agree with Buckley and disagree with Gingrich.

Gingrich complained of "diplomatic failure" and of a "deliberate and systematic effort to undermine the president's policies" by the Powell-led State Department. His attack came, unfortunately, in a speech sponsored by the American Enterprise Institute. Although he aimed at the State Department and Powell's trip to Syria, he did enormous collateral damage to President Bush both diplomatically and politically.

By parroting Sen. Tom Daschle's criticism of Bush diplomacy, Gingrich fits Winston Churchill's description of a particularly rowdy member of Parliament in Britain when he said, "He's the only case I know of a bull who carries his own china shop around with him."

Heaven knows the Department of State needs reforming and has for a long time. But isn't it interesting that when he had an opportunity to push for reform while he was speaker of the house, Gingrich didn't hold hearings and push legislation to reform the department?

When I pointed this fact out after his speech last week, he claimed I had failed to do my homework and referred to his service on the Hart-Rudman Commission, which was charged with the task of conducting a comprehensive review of American security and designing a national security strategy appropriate for the changed world of the 21st century. Based upon his service on the commission, Gingrich claims now to be "the father of homeland security." Hmmm - and Al Gore was father of the Internet?

Whether or not he is the father of homeland security, the Hart-Rudman Commission, while it fairly well diagnosed some of the State Department's problems, was conspicuously silent on the precise "reforms" it would propose to correct the problems. In fact, when Gingrich spoke to AEI, he didn't offer any specific reform proposals from the commission's report; he called for another working group to report back within six months with more grand ideas for the "transformation of the diplomatic, communications and assistance elements of the United States." Wow, Gingrich is in favor of an early spring and a late fall.

Jack Kemp

Jack Kemp is Founder and Chairman of Kemp Partners and a contributing columnist to Townhall.com.
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Jack Kemp's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.