Emmett Tyrrell

WASHINGTON -- Henry Regnery, the great publisher who founded the Regnery Publishing house in the late 1940s, was at some point in the early 1960s having lunch with Vermont Royster, the great editor of the Wall Street Journal. They were kindred spirits, and Regnery asked Royster his explanation for the Journal's rise to eminence in the world of ink-stained wretches. Royster replied that he always hired the "best minds" without regard to trendiness or cost. The Wall Street Journal has continued as the world's most credible news source and one that refused to conform to the passing prejudice and error of the journalistic herd.

        Naturally, the Journal receives ongoing abuse from the herd for its distressing independence. Yet, rarely is the criticism straightforward but rather an assault on the conservatism of the Journal's editorial page, which strikes conformist journalists as an affront and is the real cause of the herd's distress. Rather, the criticism focuses on the Journal's bottom line, its sluggish share price, and rumors that the family controlling the paper, the Bancroft family, is unhappy and about to sell it.

        The rumors of the Bancrofts' unhappiness are all highly exaggerated and quickly refuted. For this proud family whose ancestor, Clarence W. Barron, purchased the Journal and with it the Dow Jones news service in 1902, conceives of its ownership as a "public trust." That is how Roy A. Hammer, a lawyer and trustee for the entities through which the Bancrofts control the paper, described their sense of ownership. This is not so unusual. Great newspapers have always played a major role in American civic life. I said "great newspapers," not the tabs, serious newspapers, the kind that put gathering news ahead of sensationalism.

        Most of the truly profitable newspapers in the country today are essentially shopping circulars with some cheap journalism printed on those pages not devoted to shopping mall sales. The great newspaper chains take over local papers, fire journalists, and set out to fill their pages with still more advertisements. Well, they supply a service. They let readers know about the price, say, of chicken at the Giant or snow tires at the CVS. But fewer and fewer local newspapers supply much news and analysis. Great newspapers do, and not one that I know of makes a vast amount of money.


Emmett Tyrrell

R. Emmett Tyrrell Jr. is founder and editor in chief of The American Spectator and co-author of Madame Hillary: The Dark Road to the White House.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Emmett Tyrrell's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate