Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, February 01, 2007
Kathleen Parker :: Townhall.com Columnist
But He's Barbaro
by Kathleen Parker
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Do you feel the leaked information from a global warming alarmist organization is meaningful?



"He's a horse -- one of our patients -- but he's Barbaro, and he won the Derby ... and I need to make sure he makes it through the night."

-- Barbaro's nurse, Jamie DeFazio

In a week that saw Jane Fonda bashing Bush and couldabeen-president John Kerry ragging on America, it took a real stud to rivet our attention.

Barbaro, the champion racehorse who captured America's heart, finally lost the fight and was euthanized. By the outpouring of condolences and attention, you'd have thought Dale Earnhardt had died.

What was it about that horse? It is a reasonable question to ask.

Our fixation on Barbaro began during the 2006 Kentucky Derby, where the colt won by six and a half lengths. Just moments into the Preakness Stakes, which many expected him to win, he shattered his right rear leg.

It was a catastrophic injury that would have resulted in most horses being euthanized on the spot. But Barbaro was special, not least in his ability to inspire humans.

Thousands if not millions followed his ordeal at the University of Pennsylvania's New Bolton Center. Bloggers posted daily reports on Barbaro's progress; media trucks kept vigil in the parking lot; friends and strangers sent gifts, letters, e-mails and prayers.

A trust fund in his name grew to $1.2 million by the time Barbaro died. New Bolton Center doctors say the money will be used for new equipment, treatment and cures.

All this, you say, for a horse? Somebody's horse wins the Kentucky Derby each year. Horses are euthanized every day. Another race, another horse, another broken leg.

How is it that in a time of terror and war, so many could become so emotionally invested in a horse? Maybe the better question is, how could they not?

Here in steeplechase country, where signs forbid horses on sidewalks, it is not hard to find people who speak ``Horse.''

One friend I spoke to had been sitting close to the track when Barbaro fell. She learned from Barbaro's ambulance driver that people had stopped on interstate overpasses and held signs wishing the champ Godspeed.

``I've never seen anything like it,'' she said, sniffling.

``I don't cry about my own horses, but Barbaro fought so doggone hard. He really wanted to live.''

It was Barbaro's spirit, apparently contagious, that attracted crowds. Sick and injured people said they found inspiration in the colt who wouldn't quit. His fight became their fight.

Another local couple in the horse-breeding business recalled a time several years ago when one of their thoroughbreds fell ill. Thousands of people sent e-mails, while strangers called just to talk.

Everybody, it seems, has some connection to a horse, whether from childhood or heritage. We've been interacting with horses on some level since about 4,000 B.C., when we mostly ate them. Then we noticed that horses were also handy with carts, wagons, chariots and plows. Horses have been patient with our evolution.

Now we admire them, write books and make movies about them. Most children can't wait to ride a horse, and girls emerge from the womb demanding one. Not getting a pony has become a metaphor for childhood disappointment.

I didn't get my pony either.

On another level, Barbaro may have been the right horse at the right time. Americans love a champion, a winner, a striver. We identify ourselves by those lights. But since Sept. 11, 2001, we are plagued with doubt, anxiety and no small fear that we may not win this race against evil. Here to remind us of our weak resolve in that struggle are Fonda and Kerry, whose headlines collided with Barbaro's.

Fonda, who has never met a war she could get behind, showed up on the National Mall to protest the ``mean-spirited, vengeful'' Bush administration. Kerry showed up at an economic forum in Davos, Switzerland, where he couldn't find anything good to say about the nation he once meant to lead.

No wonder we fell in love with a horse.

A country driven mad by partisanship found common cause in Barbaro -- an utterly neutral reservoir of hope, beauty and determination. For a while, we were all in the race with a champion, and, for a while, we were champions, too.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Kathleen Parker is a syndicated columnist with the Washington Post Writers Group.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Kathleen Parker's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Baseballdoc
They did try to save Ruffian and even operated on her but she started fighting coming out of anestheisa and shattered her cast...then they had her put down. Barbaro was remarkable calm after his operation and tolerated confinement much better. I thought he might make it.

Barbaro's injury too severe

....Uncle Max ...

.....Obviously Handy and yourself are horse lovers and I understand this having spent several years of my youth on racetracks from hot walker to owner ...

....I am not familiar with the history of Hoist the Flag beyond the fact that he was a promising race horse who was retired to stud early because of an injury ...

....the nature of the injury would determine his chances for survival ...I don't know how severe his injury was ...a hairline crack of the cannon bone could be repaired ...

.....I watched the match race where Ruffian went down ...she broke down in a front leg and her injury was much less severe than Barbaros (front leg injuries have a better prospect for survival) but even though she would be worth a fortune as a brood mare they put her down ...

.....I watched the race where Barbaro went down ...as soon as I saw his injury I knew he was gone ...I believe the odds on his survival (even as a pet much less a stud) would be at least a billion to one ...the humane thing to do would have been to bite the bullet and put him down immediately ...

.....if you have the info on Hoist the Flag ...the nature of his injury and recovery ...give me the link ...I googled but had no luck .....COLOSSUS

it's a friggin horse!
i mean, really, what's the big deal here? a horse broke his leg. thanks to good medicine, he got better. then he got worse. then he got better again. then he got even worse, and he had to be put down, because we haven't figured out how to put a fake leg on a horse yet. what's the underlying problem here? well...nothing. i feel bad for the poor fella, and his owner and rider, and whoever else loved him. but....things that live....you, me, my dogs.....everything has to die sometime. it's just one of those facts of life. and anyone who tries to draw political parallels between a horse and democrats or republicans is just acting stupid and trying to rile ya up. either that, or they can't think of any decent news to report. myself, if i really wanted to slam bush or kerry, i think i could have thought up something better than comparing their acts to a horse's end. maybe by comparing them both to the horse's rear-end.....

mr right
Re: Your comments about thoroughbreds

"a couple centuries of breeding and we have developed a horse that can run faster than ever"

No argument there

"Can't reproduce on its own"

Excuse me? (If you want to reword that please do. I think I speak for many of us when we ask "what is the gentleman talking about?")

"Has lousy feet at best"

Sometimes - not necessarily

"In many cases unmanageable temperament"

That in all probability reflects the way the horse was treated prior to arriving at your stable. Or possibly the people you have handling them don't know what they're doing - any horse knows if the person handling him knows what he is doing or doesn't and will respond accordingly.

"And has incredibly fragile legs".

Granted - their legs are not thick enough to withstand the pounding they take on the track.

one more thing
(Ref. - Ms. Parker's reference to jfk and jane fonda's being in the news the same week as Barbaro.) William Nack, who wrote the definitive story of Secretariat, was fond of saying that before he started writing the story of Secretariat he covered politicians, but then he decided to cover the whole horse.

Get it?

Do conservatives have senses of humor?

(Loyal Democrat - is there a back door to this place? These people are getting ugly.)

Gunny G et. al.
The horse was NOT a liberal so you can leave him alone.

The horse was NOT a conservative and so he is not your hero.

He was a HORSE - A big, beautiful, wonderful, fast, brave, wonderfully gifted racehorse. And the tears of the people who raised him and who tried to save him but couldn't should put you people to shame (IOW shut you up for a while) but that apparently is asking too much. I've worked on racetracks, I've seen horses break down and I've held horses when they were being put down and it is a terribly sad thing to be part of. One time I worked for a lady who was rich as Croesus and she had a 2 year old filly who was ill and the woman refused to spend a dime to help the horse and finally we persuaded her to put the animal down because it was too far gone but NOT before she asked me if we could have it made into dog food. And this lady was a REPUBLICAN.

Baseball Doc - You are wrong in saying that the horse should have been put down immediately. Google the name "Hoist The Flag" and you will find out how wrong you are.

But in general you people should be ashamed of yourselves. He was a HORSE. Immediately you try to put the issue in liberal/conservative terms. Don't you know that there are LIBERALS reading these posts and taking down every word you say and storing it for future use against you. Their general theme will be:

Conservatives are meanies - here's the proof.

I saw the movie "The Black Stallion" starring Mickey Rooney about 10 times and I could never get through it without bawling like a baby, I'm proud to say. That scene on the beach with the seaweed? Get out of town. The ending of the race? Get out of town.

IN CONCLUSION

My sainted mother used to say "If you can't say anything nice then don't say anything at all."

But she died many years ago and her words need to upgraded to today.

STFU

Figure it out, meanies - and you know who you are.

Handy
Even the facial features of a horse are intelligent and benign. You ought not even imply that for the two idjits.

Irresponsible Slanderers
"Can you produce an analogous figure on the right who did the same kind of irresponsible slandering? One will do."

Dinesh D'Souza. That was easy.

Why Care about Barbaro?
Conservative care because he was a winner and a fighter. Liberals care because he was an underdog and a victim of "the sport of kings". The apolitical cared because he was famous and in the media spotlight for months. We all care because of the innocence of the animal. Barbaro was bred to run and to have staying power and he was true to his breeding and we admire his nobility and longsuffering. We don't recognize humans as being innocent, so we don't cut them any slack, nor should we.

Hockey Goon
I am a horse owner (about 2 dozen at present) and I have real working horses. I have to laugh at your characterization of Thoroughbreds. You are correct in that so many of the traits that have allowed horses to survive over the centuries have been bred out of them. I've had a few thoroughbreds as boarders and my general opinion is that they only have a brain cell or two to share amongst the whole breed and the ones that were here seldom had a turn. They are yet another example of how bad things would be in this world if man were truly in charge. A couple centuries of breeding and we have developed a horse that can run faster than ever but can't reproduce on its own, has lousy feet at best, in many cases unmanageable temperment, and has incredibly fragile legs. We are brilliant, are we not?

I must take exception, however, with one item. You mentioned thoroughbreds as being so delicate that simply rolling on the ground could cause strangulated intestines and death. From my experience, the hardest work horse can suffer the same fate. It may be somewhat less likely but it can and does happen anyway.

dhermesc
Bucko writes: As for horses in general, humans could not have built civilizations, or sailed the seas in exploration and trade without the horses strength and cooperation. It's long past due that we humans give credit were credit is due, to wit: Without horses, man would not have discovered the New World, gone to the Moon, or even developed computers.

---------------------------------------------------

I agree for the most part with this post in regards to horses in general, but race horses have had little to do with building civilization. They are the "toys" of those that enjoy the civilization that WORKING horses built. Many of the genetic traits that might have helped Barbaro survive had been culled out generations ago. Today's thoroughbreds are such delicate creatures that something as simple as rolling on the ground could result in strangulated intestines.

Much like how a mutt will thrive on table scraps and a little attention while a pure breed dog will die from eating a chicken bone.

Not this time
GunnyG writes: I'd bet a month's pay that he was kept alive to milk his sperm and to freeze it for later sales.
=================================================

The thoroughbred industry is the only equine breeding industry which does not allow artificial insemination. That was the only reason they tried so hard to keep him alive.





As for you, PARKER...

...look up the name "Henry Bergh", either by Google or the Internet Movie Data Base web site under the actor, "Brian Keith". Burgh's offense at the poor treatment of horses in the 19th. Century was the genesis for child welfare and labor laws of the 20th Century. YOU, "Parker", were not whipped at work because Henry Burgh objected to whipping horses.

Barbaro may be jut another horse to you, but to those who understand the greater issues other than the "just another horse", Barbaro may just start something that is beyond "just another horse". I hope so.

As for horses in general, humans could not have built civilizations, or sailed the seas in exploration and trade without the horses strength and cooperation. It's long past due that we humans give credit were credit is due, to wit: Without horses, man would not have discovered the New World, gone to the Moon, or even developed computers.

"Parker", OTOH, you are just another opinion. And we all have "one".

I agree, 2ManyHorses,..

...that Barbero's recovery from his racing injuries was nothing short of miraculous. But just like Secretariat, and my first horse of 40 years ago, it was that insidious laminitis that finally did the handsome colt in. And laminitis can strike a horse without an injury, as you probably know. It's an evil disease.

As both a horseman and a horse-lover (we both know that there can be a difference), I have no problem with the efforts of the Jackson's and Dr. Richardson. Barbaro won all his races, save the last, and especially the K'Derby. He earned the money and effort that was expended to save his life. Not unlike the Triple Crown, Barbaro could have won this fight for his life. The potential was certainly there.

Thanks Ms. Parker
Those of us here in Derby city loved and admired Barbaro; he had such drive and spirit and was a beautiful champion.

A great Champion
is gone. Ginny G and other sick cynics would not understand that the owners and public loved this horse for himself.Thank the owners for giving him a chance. And always a chance for a miracle from God-you know,the one the cynics ridicule. Instead of Barboro,tis a shame it could not have been Jimmy Carter or Jane Fonda or both.

Re: Semen collection and laminitis
Per Jockey Club rules, all breedings must occur through live cover, so collecting semen from him to freeze would have been pointless. The Jacksons have stated that they didn't, which is believable. Had he been collected and frozen, the resulting foals would have been unregisterable with the JC and therefore unable to race. In the world of thoroughbred horse racing, frozen semen is absolutely worthless.

As a horse owner for more than 20 years, the fact that Barbaro's fractures healed to the point of walking on it unbraced is a miracle. The leg was not pretty, but the recovery for that type of injury is a first for equine medicine. Laminitis (and subsequent founder) often strikes without warning and for unknown reasons. That he escaped it for 8 months (excluding the left hind, which foundered as a direct result of weight bearing rather than metabolic causes) lends hope that such extreme injuries can be overcome.

baseballdoc
I'd bet a month's pay that he was kept alive to milk his sperm and to freeze it for later sales. That is what they do to retired prize horse, bulls, etc, but in this case, since he was "retired" before his time, they had to get the most money out of him before they collected the insurance money.

Where was Peta?

.....Ms Parker...

.....Barbaro's injury was fatal to the horse the minute it happened and he should have been put down immediately ...

....a horses legs are fragile and blood circulation is crital and is sustained by movement ...in other words the horse has to walk and be able to put pressure on his hooves to maintain proper circulation ...

.....without proper circulation the horse will "founder" ..ie the lamina of the foot will seperate and the bones will drop (sort of like a fallen arch in a human) ...the shell of the hoof will shed and the dying bone will necrophy and become infected ...

.....all this time the horse will be in great pain and require strong pain killer medication ...

.....this tragedy is not about the bravery of Barbaro (any animal will fight to live) it is about the stupidity of the owners and the complicity of the vets who certainly had to know better ...

.....Barbaro was "dead" the second his leg snapped ...it is just too bad that the inevitable ending was delayed so long ...raising false hopes that a miracle cure might happen and putting the horse through a lot of unnecessary pain .....COLOSSUS

A stud
"In a week that saw Jane Fonda bashing Bush and couldabeen-president John Kerry ragging on America, it took a real stud to rivet our attention."

Yes, it did - and to the shock of some, it wasn't Bill "It's all about me" Clinton!

This Horse Inspired Some of Us
I just want to say that the Barbaro story is one that has inspired me to work even harder to protecting our rights and voting for conservatives. This country is starting to fad but a horse inspired me to not give up, to write more letters and let more friends know of the culture war and the lies going on. Thank God for Barbaro and his life meant something. I only wish people would be as strong. I also was inspired by the brave rescue works in 911 and our brave soldiers overseas but how much can they take from the assaults of the liberal left.

Touchie:
Jane Fonda did bash Bush and John Kerry ran his mouth in Switzerland about how terrible the US is. It is what it is. Can you produce an analogous figure on the right who did the same kind of irresponsible slandering? One will do.

Bless Barbaro
It is one of better parts of our humanity, that we are capable of caring this way. We took time out from the worse parts of our humanity to care about this big beautiful boy.
We also cared about the challenge and the struggle of him and his humans to beat the odds. To prevail. To win.
It's possible that if jane fonda were injured, the overpasses would stop to make way for her ambulance with well-wishers signs.
Ya think?

Goshawk

I'm with you on horses and politicians'. It's
not as hard to clean up a mess left by a horse
as a mess left by a politician.

Barbaro
is still a horse. And lots of humans still eat horse meat. I personally wish more people would be as 'concerned' about their fellow man as they were about a million dollar horse. However, now that the holidays are over, I realize I am asking alot.

Beautifuly writen Kathleen!
And a fine tribute to Barbaro! As an owner of several horses, I place a horse above a politician any day.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.