A front-page story in the Washington Post this week further muddies the issue. It describes West Rashid, a Baghdad neighborhood currently controlled by Jaish al-Mahdi, the Shia militia led by the radical and anti-American cleric Moqtada al-Sadr. The article asserts: “West Rashid confounds the prevailing narrative from top U.S. military officials that the Sunni insurgent group al-Qaeda in Iraq is the city’s most formidable and disruptive force.”
That is flatly misleading: First, the fact that there are neighborhoods controlled by Jaish al-Mahid hardly constitutes proof – or even compelling evidence -- that Sadr’s militia is “more formidable and disruptive” than al-Qaeda, the group responsible for the vast majority of suicide bombings in Iraq. Second, top U.S. military officials have said consistently that the new “surge” strategy fully underway since June 15 includes an offensive against both al Qaeda strongholds and extremist militias.
If the U.S. does have an enemy more worrisome than al-Qaeda, it’s Iran. For years, we have responded fecklessly to Iran’s acts of war – from the seizure of our embassy in 1979 to the 1983 bombing of the U.S. Marines barracks in Beirut by Iran’s proxy, Hezbollah, to the 1996 attack on our troops in Saudi Arabia to the undermining of our current missions throughout the Middle East.
Finally, last week – and with relatively little media attention -- the Senate unanimously indicted Iran for murdering Americans in Iraq. It adopted Senator Joseph Lieberman's amendment to "Confront Iran on its Attacks on American Soldiers.”
Some of these attacks have been direct. Others have been carried out by militias – such as Jaish al-Mahdi – financed by Iran and, in many case, armed and trained on Iranian soil. Hezbollah also has come to Iraq to help slaughter Americans. The amendment notes that Iran has even been facilitating the entry of al-Qaeda terrorists into Iraq. And the Tehran regime permits Ansar al-Sunna, an al-Qaeda affiliate, to maintain a base in northwest Iran.
These combatants, Sen. Lieberman observed, “are responsible for the murder of hundreds of American soldiers, and thousands of Iraqi soldiers and civilians as well.”
So yes, America has a long list of “formidable and disruptive” enemies – in Iraq and elsewhere. That’s not just a “narrative.” It’s the truth – and it ought at least to be taken into account by those debating from which battlefields Americans should flee.