Carol Platt Liebau
Recommend this article

In recent days, it’s become clear that Democrats in the U.S. Senate are determined to pass some version of a non-binding resolution that will – as General David Petraeus explained in congressional testimony – have the effect of emboldening America’s enemies. The reasons for supporting such a destructive course are varied. Some senators, like Russ Feingold, truly believe the war isn’t worth winning or can’t be won; others, like the party’s declared presidential candidates, are simply trying to score political points. Sadly, even some weak-kneed Republicans seem to be poised to join the Democratic effort to undermine the war effort and American soldiers by supporting a resolution opposing the President’s plan for sending more troops to Iraq.

The Republicans who are contemplating signing on to the Levin-Warner resolution could learn something from the Democrats’ tenacity in the decades-long “war on poverty.” For more than 30 years, despite countless mistakes and unforeseen negative consequences, Democrats have resisted the notion of surrender (and even, less commendably, even modest reforms). They have met innumerable setbacks not with retreat but with resolution, new strategies, and continued efforts to advocate the rightness of their cause (sometimes, regrettably, resorting to hysterical exaggerations and falsehoods). When it comes to the war on Iraq, wavering Republicans should model the nobler aspects of this example of Democratic resolve.

Certainly, in the “war” they’ve cared about, the Democrats have persisted despite failures that make many of those in Iraq seem minimal. After all, between President Johnson’s declaration of a “war on poverty” and the 1990’s, approximately $5.4 trillion dollars were directed to anti-poverty programs – though poverty rates in 1990 were nearly the same as those in 1960. By 2001, despite modest gains for children and the elderly, poverty rates for those 18-64 totaled 10.1%, compared to 10.5% in 1966 (data for 1964 weren’t available). Even so, Democrats have vocally, even hysterically, resisted virtually every effort to reform programs designated as part of the war on poverty, despite what might be charitably characterized as a decades-long stalemate.

Recommend this article

Carol Platt Liebau

Carol Platt Liebau is an attorney, political commentator and guest radio talk show host based near New York. Learn more about her new book, "Prude: How the Sex-Obsessed Culture Hurts Young Women (and America, Too!)" here.