Cal  Thomas
President Bush’s Monday night immigration address to the nation might have been more convincing had it come before political pressure from his conservative base made it appear his motives might be suspect.

In February, 2005, the president signed into law a bill that was supposed to add ten thousand new border patrol agents along America’s border with Mexico. But the president’s 2006 budget funded only 210 new agents. Budget restraints were cited for the drastic cutback in funding.

Now the president is asking Congress for money to hire between nine and twelve thousand new agents. He would also deploy National Guard troops to “backup” the border patrol.

Throughout his address, the president kept referring to the immigrants and their rights and desires. What about those of us born in America, or who legally immigrated to this country? Do we have a right to preserve the nation the way it was handed down to us, with our English language, our culture and our loyalty to America first with no agenda other than this country?

There is more to the immigration issue than the president revealed in his speech. The bill under consideration by the Senate runs to 614 pages. With a document that long, there is bound to be some hidden mischief. According to Robert Rector, senior policy analyst for The Heritage Foundation, the Senate bill would allow up to 193 million new legal immigrants into the United States in the next twenty years. Such a staggering number comprises 60 percent of the current U.S. population. Is our economy so strong and our national identity so weak that we could successfully absorb so many immigrants in so short a period if time, or at any time?

The rapid population growth would come not only from new immigrants, but from their family members who would also be part of the deal. Since their families are generally larger than ours (due not only to our decision to have fewer children, but also because of abortion which has claimed the lives of more than 40 million unborn American children in the last three decades) their population would overwhelm what we have here now.

This isn’t about “fairness,” or being a “welcoming society.” If anything close to the current Senate bill passes, we will be a different nation. Senator Jeff Sessions, Alabama Republican, says the Senate bill would make immigration to the United States an “entitlement.” Sessions told The Washington Times, “The decision as to who may come will almost totally be controlled by the desire of the individuals who wish to immigrate to the United States rather than the United States government.”

On Wednesday, the Senate voted 83-16 in favor of construction of a fence and 500 miles of vehicle barriers along the border. It was the first victory by conservatives who have been pushing for stronger border enforcement. Just before that vote, Senators by a 66-33 vote rejected a proposal to remove from the bill the right of illegals in the country for more than two years to apply for citizenship, thus giving the president a victory for his “guest worker” proposal.

I prefer the way the Swiss government handles immigration and citizenship to the virtual open door policy advocated by the president and the Senate bill. The Swiss appreciate tourists and businesspeople, but if one wishes to become a Swiss citizen, the government makes it difficult. The reason? The Swiss want to preserve their culture.

There is no “right” to be a Swiss citizen. Being born in Switzerland doesn’t automatically make one Swiss. The right of citizenship through descent is regulated by the government.

People who wish to be naturalized in Switzerland must live a minimum of 12 years in the country; submit to complete integration into Swiss life which includes familiarity with Swiss habits, customs and traditions; comply with the Swiss rule of law; and demonstrate they are no danger to Switzerland’s internal or external security. Local towns may add additional requirements for residence.

President Bush employed the classic “melting pot” metaphor, but changing the character and culture of America through uncontrolled immigration – legal or not – would drop a glacier in the pot that would never melt,

This is more about politics and votes. It goes to the nature of who and what we are. Current citizens had better make sure this is not an invasion masquerading as immigration.


Cal Thomas

Get Cal Thomas' new book, What Works, at Amazon.

Cal Thomas is co-author (with Bob Beckel) of the book, "Common Ground: How to Stop the Partisan War That is Destroying America".
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Cal Thomas' column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.