Pope John Paul II led a remarkable life at the center of Europe, not only dynamically rising to the top of the Catholic Church, but resisting two different totalitarian oppressors in his native Poland. His life has natural drama and provides natural inspiration. So it's not surprising that upon his death, which triggered the greatest international outpouring of grief in modern times, that the decision would be made by three different TV networks to produce TV movies about his life.
Or is it? In a broadcast television landscape endlessly littered with gratuitous vulgarity, ABC and CBS deserve applause for taking on this subject matter and daring to present a religious subject without scratching Hollywood's itch to denounce what they see as an antiquated church with outdated dogmas.
Many TV critics scratched that itch in reviewing it. They also condemned the movies as deadly dull. Matthew Gilbert of the Boston Globe sneered: "Being nice is overrated, especially when it comes to movies." Doug Elfman of the Chicago Sun-Times tried to be the class clown in giving both movies a zero: "I have to endure commercial art that is seemingly created from the waste product of an alien goat people." Perhaps the oddest line came from Robert Lloyd in the Los Angeles Times, sniffing at the CBS film: "It's admiring of its subject, sometimes to a fault. He's a saint, in the secular sense: flawlessly good and giving, with nary an outburst of temper." Wrong. The pope was not a saint in a "secular sense," but a man driven to be a saint in the deepest spiritual sense -- and will have succeeded.
Not every critic was a sourpuss. Tom Shales of the Washington Post didn't care for the ABC movie, but wrote of the CBS offering that it was "not just good but aglow, a kind of thinking viewer's holiday ornament."
ABC's movie was titled "Have No Fear," which sounds more like a superhero-movie title and bumbles the pope's trademark phrase, known to billions, but not ABC, "Be not afraid." The critics were rough on what they found to be a listless march through John Paul's memorable moments. CBS's film, simply titled "Pope John Paul II," was more like a miniseries, with its four-hour length. An edited version was screened in November and blessed by Pope Benedict XVI. Critics were especially struck by the acting of Jon Voight as he displayed both the pope's charisma and his slide into infirmity. Both firms broke from Hollywood conventions by portraying communists as villains and enemies of the Christian faithful.
Jon Stewart Attempts to "Slay" Food Stamp Fraud Allegations; Misses Real Point | Christine Rousselle
Rand Paul on NSA: “I Believe What You Do on Your Cell Phone is None of Their Damn Business” | Daniel Doherty